A comprehensive review of the United Kingdom’s challenge with young people not in employment, education, or training (Neets) has outlined a series of proposals aimed at reducing the number from nearly one million to a significantly lower level. The report, authored by former health secretary Alan Milburn, outlines a plan that combines welfare reform, job creation incentives, and education improvements to address a problem that has persisted for more than two decades with minimal progress.
Milburn’s assessment, compiled over the past year, calls for a “new deal” that would restrict certain welfare benefits for young people aged under 25 who are not working or studying, while simultaneously expanding support services and training opportunities designed to help them enter the labor market. Central to the plan is the introduction of a targeted “youth allowance” replacing elements of universal credit and personal independence payments (PIP) currently available to this age group. The new system would include a more narrowly focused “additional cost allowance” for those with health conditions, which is expected to reduce support levels for some individuals initially. A separate benefit with higher payments would be available for young people with severe and complex needs who are unlikely to ever work.
A key element is the establishment of a “duty to engage,” under which young people refusing job or training offers could ultimately lose eligibility for youth allowance. This approach pairs tighter conditions on benefits with increased investment in employment support. Milburn proposes allocating twice as much spending toward support services relative to benefits—shifting away from the current situation where over 90% of resources go to passive welfare. The plan includes the creation of a Youth Opportunity Service, providing a combination of health, employment, and practical help, along with guarantees of a training or work placement.
On the supply side, Milburn stresses enhancing education and skills development. His recommendations include new school inspection standards emphasizing employment readiness, increased early childhood interventions aiming to improve school readiness rates, expanded vocational and technical education, mandatory work experience in schools, and a substantial increase in further education places for 18- to 24-year-olds. Universities are urged to focus more on work readiness through greater employer involvement, and government apprenticeships funding would prioritize younger participants.
From the demand side, the review calls for incentives to encourage employers to hire and train young people. It proposes exempting workers aged 21 to 24 in specific sectors such as retail and hospitality from national insurance contributions to reduce hiring costs, while arguing against broader or less targeted exemptions on affordability grounds. Businesses, especially small enterprises, would be offered payments linked to creating or sustaining apprenticeships for young workers.
The financial outlook of the plan projects initial increased government spending, with costs expected to peak in the coming decade before moving toward fiscal neutrality by 2036-37. The package anticipates £5.8 billion annually by then for support, training, tax cuts, education, and health services targeted at youth, offset by associated welfare savings and increased tax revenue. Implementation would begin with an initial £500 million investment planned for 2027-28.
While the approach has been praised for avoiding framing reforms as pure austerity, concerns remain about deliverability and the wider economic context. The government’s willingness to allocate significant resources amidst competing priorities remains uncertain, and success depends heavily on the quality of support services and collaboration across departments. Critics note challenges such as the impact of automation and artificial intelligence on entry-level jobs, which often employ young people, and firms’ tendency to prefer experienced workers. The report warns that increasing employment for youth requires stimulating overall labor demand; otherwise, unemployment rates may simply shift to older workers.
Milburn also points to policies under the current Labour leadership, suggesting that national insurance increases and rising minimum wages for young people have inadvertently worsened the Neets problem by raising employment costs. He advocates slowing further wage increases for this group and easing payroll taxes to encourage hiring.
The review’s comprehensive strategy includes proposals for expansion beyond youth-specific reforms, suggesting that lessons learned could inform welfare modernization for older claimants and across all parts of the UK, despite variations in devolved welfare arrangements.
In summary, the report sets out an interventionist, multifaceted blueprint seeking to address the persistent and complex issue of youth disengagement in the UK. Its success hinges on practical implementation, sustained investment, employer participation, and broader economic conditions conducive to job growth.
