A beer garden in Queens has drawn criticism for hosting a 9/11-themed silent disco event on the 25th anniversary of the terrorist attacks that claimed nearly 3,000 lives in Manhattan. Bohemian Hall and Beer Garden in Astoria held the event on Friday, describing it as a gathering for “music, unity and remembrance.” However, the occasion sparked backlash from local residents and social media users who viewed the party as an inappropriate way to mark the somber day.
The event featured attendees wearing headphones while dancing, and was promoted on Instagram with language referencing “dancing with intention.” The accompanying promotional image, created using artificial intelligence tools, drew further ire for depicting a skyline that did not resemble Manhattan’s. Critics accused the venue of insensitivity, with one commentator on Google Reviews calling the event “incredibly gross” and accusing the organizers of self-promotion under the guise of remembrance.
Bohemian Hall responded to the criticism by defending the event and its promotional materials. The beer garden stated on social media that the flyer was designed by a U.S. Army veteran on staff who utilized AI in putting the project together. The venue acknowledged that it could have chosen a different method—or no event at all—to commemorate the anniversary, but said it opted to hold the silent disco as a form of tribute.
Despite the venue’s response, the backlash intensified, particularly on online forums. Some users expressed disbelief and frustration at what they considered a tasteless approach to memorializing 9/11, criticizing the promotion’s tone and imagery. Comments described the venue’s defense as patronizing and sarcastically referenced the emphasis on military and AI elements in the flyer’s creation.
Additionally, the event drew scrutiny over the allocation of proceeds, with reports indicating only 20% of the funds raised were donated to charity, a point that fueled further dissatisfaction among critics.
The controversy highlights ongoing sensitivities surrounding public commemorations of tragic events and the challenges organizations face in balancing remembrance with community expectations. Bohemian Hall has maintained its position, emphasizing the intent to honor those affected by the attacks through its chosen format.