A British woman who reportedly sought to end her own life was allegedly manipulated and murdered in Florida last year, according to court proceedings underway in Ocala, Florida. Sonia Exelby, 32, a music tutor from Portsmouth, traveled to the United States in October 2025 after engaging in a two-year online correspondence with Dwain Hall, 54, who is accused of killing her.
Exelby, who had a history of mental health challenges including bipolar disorder, depression, and bulimia, used a hardcore fetish website called Motherless to communicate with men who shared her expressed desire to die. Prosecutors said she encountered numerous individuals willing to harm her, but Hall, who described himself as a sadist and worshipped the Egyptian god of death, systematically groomed her and ultimately agreed to act as her “executioner.” The pair arranged for Exelby to pay Hall approximately $4,000 for the killing.
After arriving in Florida on October 10, 2025, Exelby, who told her long-term partner Stevie Hunt that she was visiting her sisters, met Hall at the airport. Two days later, Hunt found an email she had sent herself during the flight outlining her distress, remorse, and fears. This prompted him to alert Hampshire police in the United Kingdom, who then coordinated with American authorities.
Investigators discovered Exelby’s partially naked body buried in a shallow grave near Hall’s residence in Marion Oaks. She had suffered four stab wounds, and police seized a knife with her blood, as well as numerous deleted photos and videos of Exelby on Hall’s phone. Additional disturbing material depicting women being tortured and killed was also recovered.
During the trial’s opening statements, prosecutors depicted Hall as a predatory individual motivated by sadistic sexual pleasure derived from inflicting pain and death on women. They maintained that he pursued Exelby’s murder despite her apparent hesitation upon arrival in Florida. Hall has pleaded not guilty to charges of murder and kidnapping.
Exelby’s family, including her sister Gemma Isaj, testified about her longstanding mental health struggles and fear of threats encountered on suicide forums. Isaj recalled notifying authorities after Exelby expressed terror over men she met online. Meanwhile, Hunt described Exelby as a talented and kind person whose self-esteem deteriorated following her involvement with fetish websites, a factor he linked to her worsening mental state. During his testimony via video link, he stated that he had taken precautionary measures by securing Exelby’s passport to protect her.
The trial continues as the court examines the contested circumstances surrounding Exelby’s death and Hall’s role in the case.
