Andy Burnham indicated on Thursday that he may reconsider a proposal to limit jury trials for certain criminal offences, a policy introduced under Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s leadership that has faced criticism within the Labour Party.

The plan, which aimed to restrict access to jury trials in some cases, has drawn opposition from several Labour MPs, including Karl Turner. Turner’s public dissent led to the removal of the party whip, highlighting internal party divisions on the issue.

Speaking publicly, Burnham expressed reservations about the proposal, citing his own experience with the Hillsborough disaster as a factor in his concerns. “I have my concerns about the plan to restrict jury trials, partly from my personal experience, particularly Hillsborough, so I want to really look in detail at that, at that proposal,” he said. He added that his initial instincts are to avoid measures that would reduce defendants’ access to jury trials.

Burnham compared the situation to the earlier controversy over the early release scheme, noting that he wants to thoroughly examine inherited policies before confirming them.

In addition to reconsidering the jury trial proposal, Burnham revealed he has asked Chief Whip Anneliese Midgley to engage with Turner about potentially restoring his party whip. “I’ve asked the Chief Whip to speak to Karl and agree a process,” he stated, indicating a possible reconciliation within the party ranks.

The Labour leadership has not yet announced any formal changes to the plan restricting jury trials, and it remains unclear if Burnham’s review will result in an official policy reversal. The issue has sparked debate about balancing judicial efficiency with defendants’ rights to fair trials.