Cabinet ministers in the UK government are confronting a potential rebellion within the Labour Party over the approval of the Rosebank oilfield, an offshore project situated approximately 80 miles northwest of Shetland. The energy secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh, who holds ultimate authority to approve or reject the project by the end of the year, has been accused by some colleagues of privately encouraging Labour MPs to oppose the drilling plan. Fahnbulleh and her department have categorically denied these claims.

At least 75 Labour MPs have signed a confidential letter urging Prime Minister Andy Burnham to reject the Rosebank development, arguing that its approval would not lead to lower energy bills and would undermine the UK’s climate commitments. Some party sources estimate that opposition could rise to as many as 200 MPs, although senior government officials have described such numbers as exaggerated. Meanwhile, backbenchers supporting Rosebank have dismissed the letter as a “government-engineered rebellion,” and a Whitehall source suggested that many officials within the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero hold ideological objections to the project.

The Rosebank oilfield is estimated to contain around 300 million barrels of oil and has the potential to create approximately 1,600 jobs. Its development does not require new legislation or a parliamentary vote, since the project received preliminary approval under the previous Conservative government. Additionally, authorizing Rosebank would not violate Labour’s manifesto pledge against issuing new North Sea exploration licenses, which Burnham and Fahnbulleh plan to enshrine in law going forward.

Fahnbulleh recently approved drilling at the Jackdaw gasfield, citing its role in supplying the domestic market. However, she argued that Rosebank, primarily aimed at oil exports, should be assessed separately. The energy secretary stressed that decisions need to be consistent with the UK’s carbon budgets and net zero targets for 2050. She emphasized that her department’s final ruling will follow a quasi-judicial process including environmental assessments.

Within the government, there are differing views. Chancellor John Healey reportedly supports new drilling, while Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, Fahnbulleh’s predecessor and an outspoken critic of Rosebank, stated he will adhere to collective responsibility regardless of the decision. Several frontbench Labour members and parliamentary private secretaries have publicly expressed opposition to the project, with some reportedly willing to resign if it proceeds.

The issue is politically sensitive given Burnham’s recent climate leadership commitments at COP31 last year. Opponents contend that releasing fossil fuels from Rosebank would jeopardize the UK’s net zero ambitions and risk accusations of hypocrisy against the prime minister.

Labour’s trade unions Unite and GMB, along with Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra, back the project, citing economic benefits. The Conservative Party and Reform UK have also called for drilling to commence swiftly. The government faces the challenge of navigating internal divisions while addressing economic, environmental, and political considerations before a final decision is made.