Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney emphasized the country’s focus on diversifying its trade partnerships and reducing dependence on the United States during remarks at a recent summit in New York. Highlighting concerns about relying too heavily on U.S. technology and services, he defended Canada’s cautious approach to supply chains and critical infrastructure, including satellite communications.

Carney cited past tensions with the U.S., referencing former President Donald Trump’s commentary on Canada—such as his threat to acquire Greenland and describing Canada as the "51st state"—as factors influencing Ottawa’s hedging strategy. He also pointed to restrictions on Starlink’s military satellite service, Starshield, which have intermittently impacted Ukraine’s defense capabilities against Russian incursions. These incidents, the Prime Minister said, illustrate the risks of excessive dependence on a single major ally.

“It would be simpler if we could just align within the Western alliance,” Carney said, “but, you know, you can’t go through Greenland, you can’t go through 51st state, you can’t go through Ukraine and Starlink, and responsibly hold that assumption two per cent, or five per cent, or 10 per cent. And that’s a very difficult reality, but it is reality.”

When asked whether Canada might reconsider its policy of limiting reliance on the U.S. if future administrations in Washington were to restore a closer relationship with Ottawa, Carney replied that while Canada and the U.S. remain NATO allies and will continue to collaborate on defense and security, it would be prudent to maintain safeguards. Using a financial analogy, he described Canada’s policy as a “hedge” that would remain in place until circumstances clearly change.

Carney also addressed ongoing negotiations with the U.S. related to tariffs, particularly those imposed on the Canadian auto sector. He noted progress toward a bilateral agreement that would reduce U.S. tariffs currently levied at 25 percent on Canadian-made vehicles, subject to a carveout based on the U.S. content of the vehicles. The Prime Minister stressed that any agreement must safeguard the long-term viability of Canada’s auto industry.

Warning that failure to reach a deal could create opportunities for Chinese auto manufacturers to replace U.S. firms in the Canadian market, Carney’s comments drew immediate criticism from Peter Navarro, a former Trump trade adviser. Navarro accused Carney of threatening to leverage China against the U.S. and cautioned Canada against deepening economic ties with Beijing.

In recent months, Canada has scaled back tariffs on Chinese pork and seafood imports in exchange for easing restrictions on Chinese steel and aluminum shipments. This move has drawn scrutiny from Washington, which accuses Canada of serving as a transit point for Chinese metal products entering the U.S. market indirectly.

During a visit to Shenzhen, China, Carney downplayed the notion that former U.S. President Trump remains primarily concerned about Canada’s relationship with China. He reiterated Canada’s priority to resolve trade disputes with the U.S. while actively expanding trade beyond its southern neighbor, stating, “We would like to do the deal. But if the U.S. doesn’t want to do the deal, we’re busy.”