A Cook County judge on Wednesday ordered that Abdul Malik Muhammad remain in custody at Cook County Jail while awaiting retrial on murder charges, despite the recent reversal of his 2001 conviction. Judge Nicholas Kantas delivered the ruling during a hearing at the Leighton Criminal Court Building, as Muhammad, 47, appeared visibly emotional.

Muhammad is accused of fatally shooting Damone Mims on May 4, 1999, at an intersection near 76th Street and Stony Island Avenue in Chicago. His original conviction was vacated by Kantas on November 5 after the judge determined that prosecutors had withheld evidence during the initial trial, a finding that prompted the order for a new trial.

Muhammad’s attorneys argued that he should be released pending retrial, citing the significant time elapsed since the shooting and his record of rehabilitation while incarcerated. Devin Ross, one of Muhammad’s lawyers, highlighted that Muhammad earned a bachelor’s degree from Northwestern University and served as a teaching assistant there during his imprisonment. Ross contended that these achievements demonstrated Muhammad’s preparation to reintegrate into society.

However, prosecutors strongly opposed his release. Assistant State’s Attorney Linda Walls emphasized that Muhammad’s co-defendant testified that Muhammad was the shooter and that the killing was retaliatory, following a prior assault on Muhammad. Walls pointed to Muhammad’s disciplinary history in prison, including incidents of fighting and witness intimidation, arguing that he remains a risk to public safety and the judicial process. Ross noted that Muhammad has not had disciplinary issues since 2019.

Judge Kantas sided with the prosecution’s assessment of risk, stating that Muhammad’s alleged actions—shooting at a busy intersection where multiple civilians were present—constitute a “real and present threat.” Muhammad maintains his innocence, asserting he was in Seattle at the time of the shooting, staying with his grandmother after the earlier assault. His grandmother’s testimony corroborated his alibi during the original trial. Prosecutors countered that Muhammad fled to Seattle to avoid arrest.

Muhammad’s case has attracted additional attention due to ongoing litigation related to allegations of torture by Chicago police detectives during the investigation. The Illinois Torture Inquiry and Relief Commission previously found Muhammad’s claims of abuse by Detective Michael McDermott credible and referred the matter back to court. As a result, his case became part of a broader effort to appoint an independent special prosecutor—Robert Milan—to handle torture claims separately from the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office.

While the conviction has been overturned, prosecutors have not ruled out an appeal of Judge Kantas’ decision to grant a new trial. Meanwhile, Muhammad remains detained as the legal process continues.