President Donald Trump’s effort to secure confirmations for his judicial nominees during the current lame-duck session of Congress encountered obstacles as Republican opposition emerged against some of his picks. On November 18, outgoing Senator John Cornyn of Texas blocked the advancement of T. Elliot Gaiser, a Department of Justice official, by withholding his blue slip—a Senate tradition that allows home-state senators to approve or veto federal judicial nominees. Without Cornyn’s endorsement, Gaiser did not appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee for a scheduled hearing.
Gaiser, 37, nominated to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas after the recent election, has served as head of the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and previously clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito. Despite his conservative credentials, Cornyn cited concerns over Gaiser’s qualifications, noting that he is not from Texas and lacks trial experience. Cornyn criticized the White House for pushing the nomination without what he described as adequate vetting for a lifetime appointment. Cornyn has recommended former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey for the seat and indicated that the White House may now consider Fahey instead.
In contrast, Senator Ted Cruz of Texas voiced strong support for Gaiser, warning that delaying the nominee’s confirmation could leave the judicial seat vacant and potentially allow Democrats to claim it once they assume control of the Senate in January. Cruz also noted logistical challenges, saying it would be “impossible” for a new nominee to complete the FBI background check quickly enough for confirmation in this session if Gaiser is removed.
Cornyn endorsed another Trump nominee, Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan, who was nominated for a different federal judgeship following his electoral defeat by a Democrat. This distinction highlights intraparty divisions within the Republican ranks regarding judicial appointments during the transition in Senate power.
Similar resistance to Trump’s judicial nominees has surfaced elsewhere. Earlier in November, the White House withdrew the nomination of U.S. District Judge Lee Rudofsky to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals following opposition from Arkansas’ Republican senator. In Rudofsky’s place, Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland was nominated and testified before the Judiciary Committee along with other nominees on November 18.
The White House has expressed confidence that all of Trump’s judicial nominees will be confirmed by the end of the year, but the emerging opposition from Republican senators to select nominees underscores the complexities of securing confirmations amid shifting political dynamics and differing views over nominee qualifications during this final phase before Democrats take control of the Senate on January 3.
