In north-west Devon, two neighboring farmers with contrasting approaches to land management have become the focus of a new documentary capturing their evolving relationship amid stark differences over farming and conservation. Derek Gow, a rewilding advocate, has transformed his sheep farm into a haven for wildlife, while Derek Banbury continues to operate an intensive dairy and beef cattle farm on adjacent land.
The film, shot over three years, documents Gow’s efforts to reintroduce beavers, wildcats, storks, and other native species by restoring natural habitats on his property. Gow, known for his forthright views on conservation and farming practices, criticizes what he sees as misguided agricultural subsidies and environmental policies. Meanwhile, Banbury maintains a traditional agribusiness model, producing milk and beef on a large scale with tightly managed fields, prioritizing food production amid the challenges of a growing population.
Initially characterized by mutual distrust and conflict, the relationship between Gow and Banbury gradually shifts through the documentary’s narrative, revealing nuanced perspectives on each other’s work and the environmental challenges facing rural communities. Banbury openly expresses a strong commitment to farming, emphasizing the necessity of intensive methods to meet food demand. Yet he acknowledges the environmental trade-offs involved, lamenting the decline of insects and birds on his farm even as he focuses primarily on crop yields.
Key moments include tensions over wildlife impacts, such as wild boars escaping from Gow’s land into Banbury’s pastures, leading to their removal, and Banbury’s skepticism toward beavers, which are recognized by conservationists for creating beneficial wetlands. Still, Banbury concedes the importance of wildlife-friendly areas, stating a recognition that land should be set aside to support biodiversity.
Both men exhibit a shared resilience and dedication to their livelihoods, as well as a begrudging respect for one another’s convictions. Gow suggests that farmers setting aside even a small portion of less productive land for rewilding could significantly aid species recovery. Banbury’s openness to allowing some hedgerows to grow wild indicates a potential for incremental changes, provided there are adequate incentives.
Their spouses also play a role in bridging the divide, with Banbury’s wife, Linda, advocating tolerance toward wildlife and supporting efforts to open dialogue between neighbors who initially seemed to inhabit opposing worlds.
Since its release, the film has garnered positive reactions at festivals in Greece and the UK, with local audiences including farmers and residents attending special screenings. These events have fostered conversations about reconciling food production with conservation goals amid widespread ecological decline.
The documentary concludes on a note of cautious optimism, highlighting how two men tied by land and community can find common ground despite divergent views. Gow and Banbury have developed a friendship grounded in mutual assistance and respect, exemplifying the complex challenges and possibilities of rural England’s environmental future.
The film will be available in UK cinemas starting 2 October, followed by a series of on-farm screenings aimed at encouraging further dialogue between conservationists and farmers.