A federal appeals court has revived a legal challenge to an Illinois law that mandates large charitable nonprofits to disclose aggregated demographic information about their board members and officers. On Wednesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit reversed a lower court’s dismissal of complaints filed by the American Alliance for Equal Rights and the U.S. Department of Justice, sending the case back to the federal district court in Chicago.
The 2024 law, signed by Governor JB Pritzker, requires nonprofit organizations that issue at least $1 million in charitable grants annually to publicly post demographic data on their websites. This information includes aggregated metrics on race, gender, disability status, and sexual orientation of officers and board members. However, board members are not compelled to provide this information, a provision the state argued protects individual privacy and limits any compelled speech.
Illinois officials maintained that because participation in providing demographic data is voluntary, nonprofits would only post information if some board members chose to disclose their details. The state said there was no injury caused to anonymous board members or organizations that declined to participate. The appellate court, however, disagreed, suggesting it is reasonable to assume that some board members would provide the requested data despite objections from others.
The case originated in early 2025 after the American Alliance for Equal Rights, a Texas-based conservative group founded by activist Edward Blum, filed suit against Illinois and its officials, including Attorney General Kwame Raoul. The alliance brought the case on behalf of two unnamed nonprofit groups subject to the disclosure law, arguing that the measure violated constitutional protections under the First and Fourteenth Amendments, including free speech and equal protection rights. The plaintiffs contended that requiring demographic disclosures could coerce organizations to discriminate when selecting board members.
The Justice Department, under then-Attorney General Pam Bondi, joined the lawsuit, aligning with the plaintiffs’ arguments and adding the state government to the list of defendants. A federal judge initially dismissed the government’s suit and partially dismissed the alliance’s complaint. Both parties appealed the decision, and oral arguments were heard by the appeals court in September.
While the 7th Circuit recognized that the challengers have standing to bring the case, it has not yet ruled on the constitutionality of the law itself. Following the ruling, Edward Blum stated that the organization intends to continue pursuing the case to resolve the open constitutional questions, emphasizing the importance of representing the charities challenging the statute.
A Department of Justice spokesperson framed the ruling as affirming the federal government’s ability to enforce equal protection rights. Representatives for Governor Pritzker and Attorney General Raoul did not respond to requests for comment.
Earlier investigations highlighted that many large Illinois grantmaking foundations have yet to comply with the law’s posting requirements, noting a lack of enforcement mechanisms or penalties for noncompliance. The law is intended to build upon previous state transparency efforts concerning leadership diversity, including longstanding reporting mandates for state board appointees and publicly traded companies based in Illinois.
The case fits into a broader national context in which the Trump administration, during its second term, has actively sought to curtail diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs it deems unfair or unconstitutional. The administration has framed these efforts around the goal of restoring “merit” in organizational practices, marking a significant policy shift from previous approaches to these initiatives.
