Juan Soto’s defensive performance in the outfield remains a focal point of discussion among New York Mets fans and analysts. Although Soto contributes significantly to the team’s offense, his fielding skills have drawn criticism throughout the season.

Soto has seen time both as an outfielder and as the designated hitter for the Mets. Observers note that his defensive range and reliability—particularly in left and right field—have been subpar, with some describing his movements as uncoordinated or awkward. Data evaluating defensive runs saved suggest that Soto may have a negative impact on the field, including metrics such as defensive runs allowed and the frequency of misplayed balls, sometimes referred to as Almost Caught Its (ACIs).

This defensive performance contrasts with his sizable contract, which reportedly totals approximately $765 million plus additional perks, making him one of the highest-paid players in Major League Baseball. Despite concerns about his defensive capabilities, the Mets continue to utilize him in the outfield, balancing his offensive contributions against potential liabilities in the field.

The team’s handling of Soto’s position has sparked debate on the optimal way to leverage his skills while minimizing defensive weaknesses. Critics argue that shifting him more consistently to the designated hitter role could reduce defensive risks, whereas proponents highlight the value of having his bat in the lineup without sacrificing outfield depth.

As the season progresses, the Mets face decisions on how best to position Soto to maximize the team’s overall performance, weighing his offensive production against defensive drawbacks.