European leaders should directly engage with Russian President Vladimir Putin over the conflict in Ukraine, Finland’s President Alexander Stubb has urged, criticizing what he described as the “irresponsible” delegation of negotiations to the United States. Stubb, who spoke with Putin by phone last month alongside Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre, acknowledged the US role in reviving stalled peace talks but emphasized the need for Europe to take a more active role in the negotiation process.

Stubb highlighted that Europe has long relied on the US to manage dialogue with Russia, a strategy he believes must change now that a framework for discussions has been established. “European leaders should engage directly with Putin with the same message [and] common speaking points,” he said.

The Finnish president framed Europe’s current diplomatic challenge as a choice between two historical precedents: the 1945 Yalta agreement, which resulted in Soviet dominance over central and eastern Europe, and the 1975 Helsinki Accords, which eased Cold War tensions and promoted sovereignty, territorial integrity, and human rights. While Stubb expressed hope that the US would align with the Helsinki approach promoting coexistence and respect for sovereignty, he admitted the current US stance seemed closer to the Yalta model, though he believed this could evolve.

Stubb emphasized that Russia has neither won nor is likely to win the war in Ukraine. He suggested that Putin is open to engaging with Europe but described the continent as “late” in organizing itself for meaningful talks. Last week, EU leaders agreed that Russia-Ukraine negotiations would involve officials from France, Germany, Italy, Poland, and the UK, alongside representatives from the EU institutions and NATO.

The Finnish president defended the decision by himself and Støre to call Putin last month, despite criticism from some European counterparts who were not consulted beforehand. He described the call as a critical step toward shaping Europe’s negotiation team and process. Looking ahead, Stubb called for Europe to become the agenda-setter in talks with Russia, stressing the need to establish a timetable and agenda promptly.

Stubb outlined six key negotiation topics: Ukraine’s security guarantees, territorial issues, post-conflict economic recovery, confidence-building measures, a ceasefire, and ultimately broader discussions on future security arrangements.

He noted that the proposed dialogue involving national security advisers from the EU, NATO, Russia, Ukraine, and the US would focus on technical matters, with political leaders responsible for final agreements. “We have to be realistic that there will be no deal without Putin’s agreement. Putin is the one who decides in Russia,” Stubb said.

When asked about a US proposal reportedly offered to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, which involved potentially ceding the eastern Donbas region to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, Stubb declined to comment. He stressed that decisions on Ukrainian territory rest solely with Zelenskyy and the Ukrainian people but expressed support for Kyiv’s eventual NATO accession, saying, “Will Ukraine be in NATO? My answer is, I don’t know. I hope they will.”