The new Broadway musical “Wanted” opened Sunday at the James Earl Jones Theater, presenting a story set in 1893 Texas centered on two Black biracial sisters who become outlaws while passing as white. The production, created by writer and lyricist Angelica Chéri and composer Ross Baum, draws loosely from the real-life family history of Chéri’s great-great aunts, Mary and Martha Clarke, who reportedly engaged in criminal activities while navigating racial identity after Emancipation.

The musical follows Mary (Solea Pfeiffer) and Martha (Liisi LaFontaine), sharecroppers determined to claim the land their enslaved ancestors once toiled on. Facing racial barriers to opportunities, the sisters decide to pass as white and unexpectedly discover a knack for banditry. The narrative blends elements of comedy and drama but has been criticized for inconsistencies in tone and historical accuracy.

Directed by Stevie Walker-Webb, “Wanted” employs an inventive and fluid set designed by Beowulf Boritt, featuring an adjustable plantation skeleton and large scenic projections that shift between symbolic landscapes and impressionistic imagery. However, some of the visual choices, including costume design by Emilio Sosa that evokes the 1930s rather than the 1890s, along with certain effects, have been seen as distracting or incongruous with the period and storyline.

Musically, the show offers a diverse score that incorporates R&B, country, and gospel influences, highlighting the vocal talents of the cast. Pfeiffer’s blend of pop and classical tones, LaFontaine’s focused intensity, and Ledisi’s commanding presence as the sisters’ spiritual guide contribute notably to the production. Additionally, Melody A. Betts and the Kinfolk chorus inject a fervent, church-like energy into several numbers.

The plot takes a serious turn when Mary falls in love with Jesse (Bradley Jaden), a wealthy white man she chooses to marry, committing to a life fully passing as white. This decision triggers tension between the sisters and introduces themes of identity, loyalty, and sacrifice. One of the production’s most powerful moments is Mary’s solo “The Way I Am,” in which she grapples internally with the psychological cost of passing, supported by ethereal visual effects and soaring vocals.

Despite strong performances and moments of emotional resonance, the show’s pacing and narrative clarity have drawn criticism. The plot remains uneven, sometimes sliding back into cartoonish comedy that undercuts the more serious themes. Certain historical details, such as Jesse’s characterization as a former slave owner—problematic given the timeline—are ambiguous or inaccurate, further complicating the story’s framing. The show’s 2½-hour runtime also exacerbates these issues, with some musical numbers and storylines feeling overlong or unresolved.

“Wanted” has undergone multiple rewrites since its 2024 appearance at the Paper Mill Playhouse, with the creative team describing the Broadway iteration as substantially reworked. Yet, these revisions appear to have introduced dramaturgical confusion, leaving central tensions underexplored and secondary elements overemphasized.

While the production’s mixture of genres and narrative approaches occasionally creates an uneven experience, it maintains a compelling core in its portrayal of the complexities of racial identity and family loyalty in a Jim Crow-era setting. The show highlights the emotional and moral conflicts faced by its protagonists, particularly in their struggle to reconcile past trauma with their pursuit of freedom and self-definition. Whether “Wanted” will find a stronger footing with further development remains to be seen.