Ashlee Gabrysch, Chicago’s chief financial officer, resigned abruptly after just three months in the role, becoming the city’s third finance chief to depart within the past year. Her exit has intensified concerns over the financial management and oversight of Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration, prompting renewed calls for rigorous review and reforms in city governance.
Gabrysch, a former senior director at Fitch Ratings who previously analyzed Chicago’s financial condition for the credit agency, cited significant disagreements with the administration’s portrayal of the city’s budget. While Mayor Johnson’s office characterized 76% of the proposed budget fixes as structural, Gabrysch contended the true figure was closer to 56%, pointing out that the administration’s calculation excluded borrowing meant to cover legal settlements related to police misconduct. This borrowing, she warned, defers financial obligations to the future and increases interest costs, which she estimated would reach $190 million over seven years for a $350 million loan planned in 2027.
Following Gabrysch’s resignation, the Chicago City Council voted 45-5 to launch an investigation into whether the Johnson administration had made material or intentional misstatements about the city’s finances to investors, aldermen, or the public. Aldermen have expressed concerns over transparency and the accuracy of financial disclosures after reports surfaced that Gabrysch was excluded from key meetings and that some mayoral aides viewed her as a troublemaker following her public disagreements with budget assessments. The city alleges she improperly directed a $75 million pension payment, a charge Gabrysch rejects as an effort to tarnish her reputation.
The budget dispute comes amid broader fiscal challenges in Chicago, which faces $36.4 billion in unfunded pension liabilities across four pension systems. The city is slated to contribute a record $3.01 billion to these systems in the coming year. The operating budget has expanded by nearly 40% from 2019 to 2025, fueled in part by temporary federal pandemic relief funds, which have since expired while most spending levels have not declined accordingly.
Financial markets have taken notice of these pressures. Two ratings agencies downgraded Chicago’s debt earlier this year, and the city postponed a $292 million bond sale amid concerns over its fiscal health. Pension and debt service payments now consume nearly 40% of operating revenues. In a recent development, a proposed $500 million sewer bond issuance was withdrawn at the Johnson administration’s request, delaying scrutiny of the city’s financial situation before the Finance Committee and sparing acting CFO Michael Belsky from testifying.
Mayor Johnson has advocated for tax increases as a solution, including a recently proposed $25 monthly tax on employees at companies with more than 125 workers. Critics argue that this approach may discourage business growth and employment in the city. Johnson faces reelection next year amid low approval ratings, with polls reporting just 23% voter approval and only 14% support for his continuation in office.
The financial uncertainty has renewed debate over Chicago’s structural governance. Observers have called for a city charter to clearly define the powers and responsibilities of the mayor and City Council, establish enforceable oversight mechanisms such as subpoena authority, and improve transparency and budget process standards. Currently, the City Council lacks the institutional capacity and tools for effective financial oversight, relying instead on limited resources such as a five-person financial analysis office, while the mayor’s budget office operates with a staff exceeding 50.
With less than 50 days remaining before the statutory deadline for approving the city budget, the resignation of the CFO and ongoing concerns highlight the challenges Chicago faces in balancing fiscal discipline, transparency, and effective governance as it confronts significant financial obligations and market scrutiny.
