Retired IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot faces significant challenges as he seeks to form Israel’s next government, largely due to the contentious issue of military conscription exemptions for ultra-Orthodox Jews. Eisenkot, a former military leader who lost close family members during the recent Gaza conflict, must navigate delicate negotiations with ultra-Orthodox political factions that demand continued exemption for their youth from mandatory service.
The ultra-Orthodox community, also known as the Haredim, insists that young men devote themselves full-time to Torah study, viewing military service as a threat to their religious way of life. This stance entrenches a long-standing conflict in Israeli society, where the IDF plays a central role for most citizens. The draft exemption policy has persisted for decades, but it remains deeply controversial, with many Israelis viewing young Haredim as “draft dodgers.”
The current political dynamic unfolds in the aftermath of last month’s election. Eisenkot’s coalition seeks to unseat Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, who has historically relied on the support of ultra-Orthodox parties—primarily United Torah Judaism (UTJ) and Shas—to maintain power. Netanyahu has generally endorsed the exemption but has been unable to pass a legally unchallengeable law protecting it from court intervention. This failure has created an opportunity for Eisenkot, who, although his bloc won fewer seats than Netanyahu’s coalition, has been given a mandate by President Isaac Herzog to try to form a government, with backing from Arab parties outside both major blocs.
Negotiations with UTJ, which represents Ashkenazi ultra-Orthodox Jews, are ongoing but conducted discreetly, with little public acknowledgment of progress. Shas, representing Mizrahi ultra-Orthodox communities, currently remains aligned with Netanyahu and is not involved in these talks. Analysts suggest UTJ may be leveraging its position by negotiating with both Eisenkot and Netanyahu to maximize political gains.
Potential compromises being considered include temporary exemption laws or limited conscription quotas tailored to ultra-Orthodox soldiers who volunteer for service in specialized units. While these arrangements have seen a gradual increase in enlistment within the Haredi community, the military still reports a shortfall of approximately 12,000 combat soldiers amid ongoing regional tensions with Iran, Gaza, Lebanon, and Yemen.
Observers caution that even if a political compromise is achieved, legal and societal tensions could persist. The Supreme Court’s authority could still overturn legislation, and disputes over religious observance in secular spaces risk triggering further crises. According to Gilad Malach, a researcher at the Israel Democracy Institute, disagreements between secular and religious factions may strain any coalition formed under these fraught circumstances.
Eisenkot’s effort to reconcile such deeply rooted divisions underscores the broader challenge of balancing Israel’s military imperatives with the religious and cultural autonomy claimed by significant segments of its population. The outcome of these negotiations will have far-reaching implications for the stability and direction of Israel’s next government.
