Highways officials missed multiple opportunities over the past year to identify and address faults in more than 150 speed cameras across England, raising concerns about the safety and reliability of enforcement on smart motorways. A recent report revealed that despite being notified by police in January 2025 about the camera defects, National Highways delayed action and did not inform the public until December of the same year.
The faulty cameras, which cover around 440 miles of major roads including smart motorways designed to enhance safety through variable speed limits, have been out of commission since December 2025. Authorities have identified approximately 2,650 wrongly issued speeding fines dating back to 2021, though the actual number is projected to be significantly higher due to the cameras’ malfunction.
Smart motorways have faced ongoing scrutiny amid safety concerns, with variable speed limits intended to reduce accidents and fatalities. The failure to promptly address the defective equipment has further heightened fears about the risks posed by these roads. Critics argue the lapses could undermine public trust in traffic enforcement and the broader smart motorway system.
Political tensions surfaced around the timing of the report’s release. The findings were shared during a period of intense focus on other government matters in Westminster, notably the unveiling of the Milburn Report aimed at tackling youth unemployment. The delay in public disclosure drew criticism from opposition figures, with the Conservative shadow transport secretary Richard Holden accusing the Labour government of negligence. Holden stated that thousands of drivers were unjustly penalized while ministers failed to respond adequately to repeated warnings, calling the situation an example of “Labour ministers asleep at the wheel.”
The Automobile Association’s president, Edmund King, emphasized the problem was not merely technical but also managerial, criticizing the lack of urgent response that motorists deserved. He underscored the importance of accurate and reliable motorway technology in maintaining road safety and public confidence.
In an official statement, roads minister Justin Madders affirmed that safety remains a top priority and highlighted ongoing efforts to strengthen enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with traffic laws. Meanwhile, National Highways confirmed that the contract with the US-based firm Verra Mobility, the operator managing the affected cameras, will be terminated early. Originally scheduled for replacement in 2028, the transfer of operational responsibilities is now set to be expedited to prevent further disruptions.
As investigations continue, officials are under pressure to restore faith in traffic monitoring systems and to address longstanding issues associated with England’s smart motorways.
