The challenge of integrating nearly one million young people classified as not in education, employment, or training (Neets) into the labor market remains pressing, with former Labour minister Alan Milburn proposing measures aimed at incentivizing employers to hire this group. Milburn’s recently published report highlights the significant financial barriers associated with youth employment and calls for policies that reduce the cost and risk of hiring young workers.

Milburn argues that current regulations and costs create a disincentive for businesses, particularly small firms operating with narrow profit margins, to recruit Neets. He suggests lowering the statutory minimum wage for these young workers and reducing or eliminating employer national insurance contributions as means to improve their employability. Additionally, he recommends delaying statutory benefits such as sick pay and parental leave for young hires to further decrease employer obligations. Importantly, he advocates making it easier for employers to terminate workers who do not meet performance expectations, aiming to reduce the perceived risks of taking on young and often inexperienced employees.

The report also proposes the creation of a youth employment cost index, designed to periodically publish an analysis of how government policies cumulatively impact the cost of hiring young people. Milburn suggests releasing this index every two years to provide transparency and inform policy adjustments.

Business leaders have broadly welcomed aspects of the report, though some differ on the recommended timeline for reducing employer national insurance. James Reed, chief executive of Reed Recruitment, supports the overall approach but disputes Milburn’s suggestion of a five-year “glide path” to lower national insurance thresholds for workers aged 21 to 24. Instead, Reed advocates for an immediate reduction, particularly targeting sectors like retail and hospitality, which employ large numbers of young people.

The financial burden on employers has significantly increased in recent years. Since 2011–12, the real-terms cost of hiring a young worker has risen by 48 percent, from approximately £17,600 to £26,100. Notably, over half of this increase—around £4,700—has occurred in the past three years alone. The rise includes contributions from Labour’s policies, such as increased minimum wages for 21- and 22-year-olds, and government decisions under Chancellor Jeremy Hunt that extended the national living wage to these age groups in 2024. Other factors contributing to higher employment costs include pension auto-enrollment, the apprenticeship levy introduced under former Chancellor George Osborne, and other regulatory requirements.

Critics of current policy assert that these cumulative costs, combined with stringent workplace regulations, are key drivers behind youth unemployment. They contend that unless these obstacles are addressed openly, subsidies, training programs, and governmental guarantees will have limited effect in improving job prospects for Neets.

While Milburn’s report confronts these issues, it stops short of fully condemning past government decisions, such as the employer national insurance increase introduced in 2024, reflecting a caution to maintain cross-party support for his proposals. The debate continues as policymakers weigh the need to balance worker protections with creating incentives for businesses to hire young workers facing significant entry barriers.