On the day of the recent U.S. midterm elections, President Donald Trump unexpectedly announced his intention to cut the annual $3.8 billion military aid the United States provides to Israel. This subsidy, which accounts for roughly one-sixth of Israel's peacetime defense budget, has long been a cornerstone of the U.S.-Israeli alliance and a key element sustaining their military cooperation. Israeli officials, who believed negotiations to extend a decade-long memorandum of understanding established under former President Barack Obama were ongoing, expressed surprise and concern at Trump’s public declaration.
The announcement marked a significant moment in a relationship that has been regarded as pivotal in shaping Middle East geopolitics for decades. Both former and current officials on both sides describe a “sea change” in bilateral ties, worsened by the fallout from the Hamas attacks on Israel on October 7, 2023, and Israel’s subsequent military response in Gaza. While the U.S. initially rallied behind Israel, growing criticism emerged over the conduct of the conflict, the humanitarian impact in Gaza, and the escalation surrounding Iran, a development many in Washington interpret as being influenced by Israel.
This shift in sentiment has permeated U.S. domestic politics. The Republican Party’s unexpectedly poor midterm performance has been partly attributed to voter dissatisfaction over the Iran war and the U.S.-Israeli relationship, with some Republicans and influential figures calling for a reevaluation of the alliance. JD Vance, a prominent Republican and contender in the 2028 presidential race, publicly stated that a major voter demand was for the U.S. to change its ties with Israel, a view echoed by Donald Trump Jr. Additionally, the pro-Israel lobby Aipac faced challenges in the midterms, as some of its endorsed candidates were defeated by opponents critical of Israel.
Supporters of Israel in the U.S., including pro-Israel donors, acknowledge that poor communication regarding Israel’s military actions, particularly civilian casualties and infrastructure destruction in Gaza, has compounded negative perceptions. Yet these critics do not necessarily fault the Israeli government for its actions, rather the failure to effectively explain the military rationale.
The strain in the alliance has been building for years amid Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s political strategy. Netanyahu’s alignment with Republican leadership figures, especially during the Trump administration, is seen by many as having eroded bipartisan support in Washington, weakening relations with Democratic White Houses, including those of Barack Obama and Joe Biden. Netanyahu’s leadership, particularly through the formation of Israel’s most right-wing government, and his contentious approach to U.S. politics—including a 2015 speech to Congress that alienated many Democrats—has drawn criticism from former Israeli officials and diplomats.
Historically, Israel has relied on unwavering U.S. support, buttressed by substantial foreign aid exceeding $300 billion since World War II and agreements ensuring Israel’s qualitative military edge in the region. This support has included secret arrangements and broad political consensus in both U.S. parties. However, recent developments have challenged this consensus amid Israel's increasing international isolation and shifts in U.S. public opinion. A recent poll found 62 percent of Americans hold an unfavourable view of Israel’s government, with disapproval extending across political and Jewish communities in the U.S.
Looking ahead, analysts question whether Israel can repair ties with the U.S. administration. Gadi Eisenkot, currently seeking to form a coalition to replace Netanyahu, might attempt to restore some Western support by halting West Bank settlement expansion and addressing settler violence against Palestinians. Yet some experts caution that fundamental Israeli security policies, such as maintaining control over Gaza and Lebanon, will remain unchanged regardless of leadership shifts.
On the U.S. side, political observers anticipate that discussions about the future of the Israel relationship will play a significant role in upcoming election campaigns. As one former State Department official noted, the evolving discourse around Israel will shape the positions of Democratic presidential candidates and signal how the alliance may continue to transform in the years ahead.
