A motorist who was unable to pay for parking due to a faulty ticket machine may have grounds to challenge a subsequent parking charge notice, according to recent guidance on private parking enforcement. The issue arose when a driver attempted to pay £1.80 at a retail park using coins but found the coin slot jammed. The driver then tried to complete the payment by credit card but received no printed receipt and was uncertain whether the payment had processed. Despite these difficulties, the driver continued their shopping and later received a parking charge notice demanding £100, or £60 if paid within 14 days.
Experts advise that in such situations, motorists have a valid basis to appeal, particularly under a new Private Parking Code of Practice introduced by the government and presented to Parliament last month. This code addresses scenarios where payment equipment is faulty, requiring parking operators to clearly inform motorists about alternative payment options and instructions on what to do if machines are out of order. Notably, the code’s Appeals Charter states that parking charges should be canceled if payment machines are not operational and no reasonable alternative payment methods are available.
Drivers facing similar charges are recommended first to check their bank or credit card statements to confirm whether a payment was successfully processed. They should then contact the parking operator, detailing the situation, providing evidence such as payment records, and requesting an investigation into the machine’s status, maintenance logs, and the signage instructions posted at the site.
If the operator rejects the appeal, drivers can escalate the matter to an independent adjudication service. Appeals may be submitted to Parking on Private Land Appeals (POPLA) if the operator is a member of the British Parking Association, or the Independent Appeals Service when the operator belongs to the International Parking Community.
It is important to note, however, that the new government code does not apply retroactively. Charges issued before the introduction of these new rules are still subject to the previous enforcement framework, which did not explicitly guarantee cancellation due to equipment malfunction. Motorists therefore should carefully review the timing of their parking charge notice in relation to the implementation of the updated code when considering their options.
