A judge in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by outgoing Republican Rep. Max Miller against his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, ruling that her claim that he once threw boiling water on her was "substantially true." The court also ordered Miller to pay approximately $77,000 in attorney’s fees to Moreno.

The lawsuit stemmed from allegations of domestic abuse made by Moreno over the summer, which emerged during Miller’s reelection campaign. Miller lost his bid for reelection on November 3, with the allegations playing a significant role in the political fallout. Miller has denied the accusations and has not faced criminal charges.

Moreno’s legal team questioned Miller’s credibility throughout the proceedings, pointing to an audio recording in which Miller allegedly admitted to dousing Moreno with hot water. “Emily Moreno has been thoroughly vindicated,” said Subodh Chandra, Moreno’s attorney.

Experts on domestic abuse have noted that lawsuits such as Miller’s are sometimes used as part of a tactic known as Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender (DARVO), which attempts to manipulate public perception of abuse allegations. Jennifer Freyd, a psychology professor at Oregon State University, characterized Miller’s defamation suit as reflecting this pattern. “This is public... he’s doing it in front of everybody,” she said.

Miller’s attorney, Aaron Minc, rejected claims that the lawsuit was a strategic tactic, stating that it was “entirely warranted and was brought based on egregious facts and defamatory statements.” He said the legal team plans to appeal the dismissal.

Miller and Moreno divorced in 2025 and share a child. Moreno is the daughter of Senator Bernie Moreno, who has publicly supported his daughter’s credibility and expressed concern for his granddaughter’s well-being.

The allegations surfaced amid investigations following a report that the couple’s daughter was found with a broken collarbone and bruising consistent with a hand print. A child services investigation deemed the abuse claims “unsubstantiated.” Police reports describe Moreno recounting incidents involving hot water being thrown on her, as well as other episodes of physical and emotional abuse, including being threatened with a gun.

During a police interview, Moreno became emotional and expressed reluctance to discuss the abuse, stating a fear that no one would believe her. Experts note that fear of disbelief is a common barrier that prevents domestic abuse victims from coming forward, even in high-profile cases.

In his court filing, Miller alleged that Moreno and her lawyer orchestrated “a defamatory campaign” aimed at damaging his character, undermining his reelection chances, and falsely portraying him as violent and abusive. The judge’s ruling effectively rejected these claims, siding with Moreno’s account of events.