Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. cautioned against efforts to restructure the Supreme Court by changing its size or imposing term limits on justices, warning that such measures could undermine the judiciary’s long-standing independence. His remarks came during a black-tie dinner hosted by the American Enterprise Institute on Monday, as Democrats prepare to assume control of Congress in January and push for reforms aimed at the court.
Although Alito did not cite any specific proposals or directly address the upcoming political shift, he sharply criticized what he described as a concerted campaign to influence the court’s decisions through pressure tactics. He said opponents of recent Supreme Court rulings have sought to intimidate justices or damage the court’s reputation in hopes of prompting structural changes.
“If that campaign succeeds, the Supreme Court as an institution will be fundamentally changed, and perhaps permanently,” Alito told attendees at the National Building Museum in Washington. He framed the challenge facing the court as a question of whether it can remain an independent body that resolves cases based on legal principles rather than political considerations.
The Supreme Court’s conservative majority, of which Alito is a leading figure, has issued rulings in recent years that reversed established precedents, including overturning the constitutional right to abortion established by Roe v. Wade, curtailing race-conscious admissions policies at colleges, and weakening federal regulatory authority. Alito authored the 2022 majority opinion that ended the nationwide right to abortion.
Public confidence in the court has declined amid these decisions. A September survey by Marquette University Law School found that a majority of Americans believe justices are motivated primarily by politics rather than law. This drop in approval has fueled Democratic calls for reform efforts such as court expansion, term limits, and enhanced ethics rules.
Following the court’s recent decision to significantly curtail the Voting Rights Act, members of the Congressional Black Caucus vowed to pursue “aggressive” reforms, including instituting term limits to restore the court’s legitimacy. Meanwhile, Representative Hakeem Jeffries, the likely next House speaker, has emphasized the need to “clean up the mess at the Supreme Court.”
While Democrats have been particularly critical, some Republican figures, including former President Donald Trump, have also expressed frustration when justices they appointed have ruled against their interests. Alito and Justice Clarence Thomas have been viewed as the most supportive of Trump’s policy agenda on the court. Speculation about Alito’s potential retirement to allow Trump a final appointment before the Senate changes hands has been dismissed by the justice, who reportedly plans to remain through the current term concluding next summer.
Alito described the judiciary as the weakest branch of government, relying on “the sufferance of the other more powerful branches” to maintain its authority. He stressed that the court’s survival depends largely on maintaining popular support for an independent judicial system.
