Two weeks after taking over as chief executive of Deutsche Bank in 2018, Christian Sewing was confronted with a severe internal crisis involving the lender’s failure to sever ties with 28,000 problematic clients within its investment banking unit. The bank admitted to regulators that it was effectively operating "outside of law and order," prompting Sewing to label the situation a “katastrophe.”

Sewing, who has led Germany’s largest bank for over eight years, has been credited with overseeing a significant restructuring that improved Deutsche Bank’s profitability and stock performance. However, an extensive leak of more than 15 million internal documents reveals persistent issues with internal controls, risk management, and organizational weaknesses throughout his tenure.

Deutsche Bank, once the world’s largest bank by assets before the 2008 financial crisis, remains a key institution in Europe’s largest economy. It employs around 90,000 people across 55 countries and eclipses Germany’s second- and third-largest lenders combined. Despite public portrayals of Sewing as a cautious leader focused on cutting costs and scaling back ambitions, internal communications depict him at times pushing the bank to take on more risk and adopt a more aggressive business culture.

Shortly after his appointment, Sewing consulted with Friedrich Merz, a future chancellor of Germany and then-chair of the German arm of BlackRock—a major Deutsche Bank shareholder. Sewing described the bank as using its "last bullet" and acknowledged Merz’s urging that it should be transformed into a “leading player” in the national interest. Publicly, Sewing vowed at the May 2018 annual shareholder meeting to make Deutsche Bank “a bit more boring” and to lead it “for the benefit of society.” Internally, however, he acknowledged that the bank’s control environment had grown excessively rigid and signaled a desire to reduce the layers of oversight that risk hampering business.

This shift in tone raised concerns among regulators. The European Central Bank (ECB), Deutsche’s principal supervisor, reviewed a speech in which Sewing encouraged staff to pursue a “hunter mentality” for new business, stressing the need to balance ambition with compliance. Deutsche contends that Sewing’s full remarks underscored the importance of abiding by risk limits and managing controls diligently.

Regulatory scrutiny intensified over the years. By 2019, the German financial regulator BaFin demanded that board members, including Sewing, take personal responsibility for addressing critical shortcomings. Sewing expressed frustration with the heightened accountability but retained responsibility for resolving the issues.

One persistent challenge involved improving client vetting procedures. For years, Deutsche’s “know your customer” (KYC) processes were internally disparaged as career-threatening, and audits by KPMG consistently identified severe deficiencies in client data quality. In 2015, Deutsche became embroiled in a major money-laundering scandal involving “mirror trades” used by Russian clients to move roughly $10 billion out of Russia. The bank subsequently paid $630 million to resolve investigations.

Despite repeated promises to BaFin to rectify KYC problems by 2017, Deutsche fell short, prompting the regulator to appoint KPMG as an external monitor in addition to its role as auditor. Over six years of oversight, KPMG reported ongoing failures, warning the supervisory board’s audit committee in 2019 that the bank was merely “firefighting.” In response, board chairman Norbert Winkeljohann urged Sewing to take “urgent action.”

Deutsche Bank maintains that major improvements in client screening were largely completed by 2024 and continues to emphasize its commitment to enhancing controls and fostering a culture of integrity. Nonetheless, the leaked documents shed new light on the operational and cultural complexities faced by one of Europe’s most politically connected and systemically important banks during Sewing’s leadership.