KPMG has completed a pilot project deploying artificial intelligence (AI) to conduct audits, finding the technology to be nearly as effective as human auditors in many respects, while emphasizing that human expertise remains indispensable. The pilot, carried out earlier this year, involved multiple AI agents reviewing the financial statements of an unnamed FTSE 250 company in parallel with a conventional audit.

Cath Burnet, KPMG UK’s head of audit, said the AI audits aligned closely with the outcomes produced by the firm’s accounting teams and, in some cases, delivered superior insights by rapidly processing extensive datasets. The AI’s ability to analyze full data populations rather than relying on sampled data marks a significant shift, enabling a higher level of assurance.

The initiative reflects ongoing efforts to integrate advanced technology into auditing practices. While AI tools have been increasingly utilized to assist auditors, KPMG’s pilot sought to explore the potential of AI agents to collaborate throughout the entire audit process, moving beyond supplementary roles.

Burnet noted that the experiment reinforced the continued necessity of the human element in auditing. Professional judgment and an in-depth understanding of the business context remain critical components of the audit process. “Our auditors having the right technical knowledge and understanding of the business to apply their professional judgment was really key,” she said.

The AI systems demonstrated clear benefits in enhancing audit quality, particularly in risk assessment and data analysis. They could handle large volumes of information more quickly and thoroughly than human auditors could, improving the efficiency and depth of audit procedures. Burnet likened this capability to replacing a fishing net dipped into a river with one stretched across the entire waterway, illustrating the broader scope of data coverage.

The use of AI also promises to alleviate auditors from repetitive tasks, allowing them to focus more on complex issues and engage in more meaningful discussions with clients. Despite the promising results, Burnet emphasized that AI is unlikely to replace auditors altogether. She stated that KPMG intends to continue developing its AI initiatives but maintains the view that audits will require human oversight and intervention for the foreseeable future.

The pilot project underscores a cautious yet optimistic outlook on the evolving role of AI in auditing, highlighting both its potential to improve the thoroughness and efficiency of financial reviews and the enduring value of human judgment in ensuring audit quality.