A Labour Member of Parliament has raised concerns that the government’s proposed Conversion Practices Bill could inadvertently criminalize parents engaging in difficult but necessary conversations with their children. Preet Kaur Gill, Labour MP for Birmingham Edgbaston and former health minister, argued that existing legislation already provides sufficient protections for children at risk of harm, cautioning that the new bill may blur the line between reasonable parenting and abusive conduct.

Drawing on her 18 years of experience in social work and children’s services, Gill addressed a joint committee scrutinizing the draft legislation, emphasizing that the Children Act 1989 empowers social workers and local authorities to intervene when there are reasonable grounds to suspect a child is suffering or at risk of significant harm. She cited an example of a child whose parents threatened to expel them from the home unless they ceased expressing that they were gay, noting that professionals can already act promptly to protect children under current laws without needing to determine if the behavior qualifies as a “conversion practice.”

Gill also raised concern over the bill’s vague definition of abusive conduct, pointing out that references to emotional or economic pressure lack clarity, which could lead to uncertainty for families regarding what behaviors amount to criminal abuse versus standard parenting. She warned that the introduction of new protection orders under the bill risks overburdening the family courts, which currently take an average of 37 weeks to resolve care and supervision cases.

While Gill did not oppose the idea of enhancing criminal powers to protect adults from conversion practices—especially those involving pressure by people in positions of trust—she stressed that ministers must first clarify why existing laws are insufficient before enacting new legislation.

Baroness Cass, who recently conducted a review of NHS gender services, has also withdrawn support for the bill. She expressed worries about a chilling effect on healthcare professionals, who may fear accusations of unprofessional conduct despite providing appropriate and ethical care.

Government officials maintain that current laws do not adequately address abusive conversion practices, particularly those involving non-physical abuse, single incidents, or actions by spiritual or community leaders not personally connected to the victim. They also cite gaps related to cases where individuals are taken abroad for such practices.

Responding to criticism, a government spokesperson stated that parents will not be criminalized for questioning or challenging their child’s identity or for having difficult conversations. The government emphasized that the bill’s definition of abusive conduct aligns with existing legal standards familiar to courts, police, and prosecutors. They added that this legislative effort aims to address long-standing delays in protecting LGBT+ individuals from abusive practices intended to change their identity.