The Court of Appeal has ruled against Timothy Bunting in a dispute over tax relief related to a loan he made to a company controlled by his wife. The court held that for capital loss relief under section 253(3) of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 to apply, the loan must remain “outstanding” in the sense that it is still legally due and recoverable. Because Bunting had relinquished his right to pursue repayment of the loan in exchange for shares of no significant value, the debt was no longer considered outstanding.

Bunting had provided unsecured, interest-free loans totaling £3,452,771 to a company engaged in trading sports history books and memorabilia, where his wife was the sole director and shareholder. After the company's business declined, he agreed to convert £2.2 million of the loan into shares of equal nominal value but effectively worthless at the time of issue. This conversion included the release of the company’s obligation to repay that portion of the loan.

When Bunting sought capital loss relief on the unrecoverable loan amount, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) rejected the claim. The Special Commissioners initially affirmed HMRC’s position, interpreting “outstanding” as “not paid” and “irrecoverable” as “impossible to recover.” However, the First-tier Tribunal later sided with Bunting, reasoning that because the loan amount had not been “paid” but converted into shares, the debt remained outstanding under the tax law, allowing for relief.

The Upper Tribunal overturned the First-tier Tribunal’s decision, clarifying that the critical factor was whether the loan remained legally enforceable, not merely unpaid. It held that the loan ceased to be outstanding once Bunting gave up his right to demand repayment when accepting worthless shares. Bunting appealed, seeking further clarification on the meaning of “outstanding” within the statute.

In its judgment, delivered by Lord Justice Newey, the Court of Appeal endorsed the Upper Tribunal’s interpretation that an outstanding loan requires a continuing legal obligation for repayment. The court rejected arguments that this interpretation could yield unintended conflicts with insolvency law. It noted that the statutory context and comparative provisions consistently treat “outstanding” as “remaining legally due,” rather than simply “unpaid.” This distinction was crucial because relief under section 253(3) is only available where an amount remains recoverable in law but has become irrecoverable in practice.

Ultimately, the court concluded that since Bunting had released the company from its repayment obligation, no amount of the loan remained legally due. Consequently, he was not entitled to claim relief for a capital loss on the converted portion of the loan. The ruling upheld prior decisions emphasizing the importance of the legal status of the debt in determining eligibility for tax relief.