Rugby greats Richie McCaw and David Pocock have both named George Smith as the standout opponent of their careers, reigniting discussion over who is the greatest openside flanker in the sport’s history. The pair, speaking at a recent event in Sydney hosted by former Wallaby Peter FitzSimons, hailed Smith as a player who consistently set himself apart on the field.

McCaw, a two-time World Cup winner with New Zealand and often cited as one of rugby’s all-time best players, recalled first facing Smith in 1999 during an under-19 match at the Olympic Stadium. He described Smith’s level of performance as unlike anything he had experienced at that point, praising his football intelligence and ability to influence games across multiple areas.

Pocock, who idolized Smith during his youth and later became his teammate with both the Wallabies and the Brumbies, echoed similar sentiments. He highlighted Smith’s remarkable timing and presence in critical moments during matches, describing him as a player who consistently made decisive contributions when the stakes were highest.

Smith’s career spanned 111 Tests for Australia, and his impact at openside flanker has placed him firmly in the conversation alongside other notable figures in the position. The event also featured the family of the Tancred brothers—Harry, Jim, and Arnold—who similarly made contributions to Australian rugby’s back row, linking past and present through a recreated family photo.

While McCaw, Pocock, and Smith are frequently cited in debates over the greatest flanker, other former players also receive consideration. South Africa’s Francois Pienaar and Schalk Burger are notable for their World Cup successes and leadership roles. Sam Warburton is credited with leading Wales to some of their finest winning runs, while France’s Thierry Dusautoir earned acclaim for his outstanding leadership in their 2011 World Cup final appearance.

England’s Neil Back and Australia’s Michael Hooper, who played 125 Tests, are also recognized for their high work rate and consistent elite performances. Ireland’s Sean O’Brien is regarded as the best openside produced by his country, and Sir Michael Jones, a pioneering All Black who achieved legendary status despite personal convictions limiting his play schedule, remains an iconic figure in the role.

The ongoing debate about the all-time best openside flanker highlights the diverse qualities that define excellence at the position. Smith’s recognition by two of rugby’s most accomplished flankers underscores his influential legacy in the sport.