A doctor who provided key expert testimony leading to the conviction of Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients due to safety concerns during the trial, an investigation has revealed.
Professor Peter Hindmarsh, whose evidence supported the prosecution’s claim that Letby poisoned two babies with insulin, was excluded from clinical practice by University College London Hospitals NHS Trust (UCLH) shortly after he completed giving evidence in court. Letby was convicted at Manchester Crown Court of murdering seven infants and attempting to kill seven others, and she is currently serving 15 whole-life sentences while maintaining her innocence.
According to documents obtained by the investigation, UCLH suspended Hindmarsh’s clinical duties in March 2023, less than three weeks after his final day of testimony. A medical director at the trust informed the General Medical Council (GMC) that Hindmarsh had provided independent medical advice on three pediatric patients despite the imposed restrictions. UCLH judged that it was unsafe for him to continue treating patients.
These restrictions and the exclusion from practice were not disclosed to the jury during Letby’s trial. Additionally, a medical tribunal imposed further limitations on Hindmarsh’s work the following month, a development that the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said it was not made aware of.
Earlier, Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH) ended Hindmarsh’s honorary consultant contract in July 2022 after raising concerns with the GMC about his diagnosis and treatment of patients. The GMC later launched an investigation, which concluded without a formal outcome after Hindmarsh voluntarily relinquished his medical registration in 2024.
A representative for Hindmarsh declined to comment on the hospitals’ concerns, the restrictions placed on his practice, or what information he disclosed during the trial. The situation has raised questions regarding the transparency of expert witness vetting and the disclosure of professional fitness to practice during high-profile criminal proceedings.
