A recent national poll reveals that more American Jews express approval of New York City Mayor Jamaal Mamdani’s performance than of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s leadership. The survey of over 1,000 Jewish Americans, conducted in June by the Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, indicates shifting attitudes amid ongoing conflict in Gaza and broader political developments.

The poll shows that 44% of American Jews view Mamdani favorably, compared with 39% who disapprove. In contrast, Netanyahu’s approval rating among the same group is considerably lower, with only 32% viewing him positively and 59% negatively. Across the wider American public, Mamdani’s approval stands at 27% against 28% disapproval, while Netanyahu’s approval is slightly higher than among Jews, at 41%, resulting in an 18% net disapproval rating.

Mamdani’s relatively higher favorability among Jewish Americans is notable given his contentious relationship with many within the Jewish community. The mayor faced significant opposition during the 2025 election from Jewish voters and has been openly critical of Israel throughout his political career. Specifically, Mamdani has declined to endorse Israel’s existence as a Jewish state and has not explicitly rejected the use of the slogan “globalize the intifada.” These positions have raised alarm among Jewish leaders who link such rhetoric to rising antisemitism and increased threats against Jews in New York City and nationwide. Mamdani also drew criticism for skipping the recent Israel Day Parade in Manhattan.

Despite this, Mamdani has asserted that his critiques of Israel are not antisemitic and emphasizes his attentiveness to Jewish concerns. City Hall did not immediately comment on the poll.

The survey’s findings appear to reflect broader shifts within the American Jewish community, particularly among younger and more secular members who tend to identify with liberal or progressive political views. Historically supportive of Israel, many American Jews are now expressing increasing unease, especially in light of Netanyahu’s administration endorsing contentious military actions in Gaza and Lebanon, escalating settlement activity in the West Bank, and aligning with former President Donald Trump’s confrontational stance toward Iran.

The poll also highlights divergent perceptions of the conflict in Gaza. Approximately 30% of Jewish respondents believe Israel has committed genocide there, while around half reject that characterization and about 20% remain uncertain. Among the general American population, similar numbers accuse Israel of genocide, though only 20% deny it, with about half undecided.

Additionally, the survey indicates that Jewish Americans are less likely to approve of President Trump’s performance than the overall American public.

With a margin of error of 5%, the poll underscores evolving attitudes toward Israeli leadership and policy among American Jews, particularly the complexities surrounding generational and ideological divides within the community.