A man is on trial in Florida accused of killing Sonia Exelby, a British classical musician and music tutor from Portsmouth. During the proceedings, the defendant, Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old mechanic, told investigators that Exelby had previously sought out other users of an online fetish website in an attempt to end her life but that they had ultimately “cowarded out” after developing feelings for her.

Exelby traveled to the United States in October 2025, where prosecutors allege she met Hall in what they describe as a sadomasochistic pact resulting in her death. Hall initially denied knowing Exelby during a four-hour police interview, but later admitted to communication with her over several years via the now-defunct website Motherless. He claimed Exelby had expressed a persistent desire to be tortured and killed.

During testimony, Gemma Isaj, Exelby’s sister, described her sibling’s long-standing struggles with bulimia, self-harm, and bipolar disorder, attributing these issues to childhood trauma. Stevie Hunt, Exelby’s fiancé, characterized her as a “lovely human being” with very low self-esteem. Prosecutors maintain that Hall assumed the role of her “executioner.”

In a recorded interview conducted on October 17, 2025, Hall stated that Exelby had attempted suicide multiple times and sought help from several men online to carry out her wish to die, but that each had backed away. “She was supposed to meet up with a few guys but they fell in love with her and cowarded out,” Hall said. He also said he had tried on numerous occasions to dissuade her.

Authorities identified Hall as a primary suspect after detecting unauthorized use of Exelby’s debit card, amounting to $1,200 charged to his business. Hall provided an account of their time at a remote cabin Exelby had rented on October 10, describing their sexual encounter as relatively mild compared to earlier discussions, involving “light choking” but no ropes or other more extreme elements.

Hall admitted to recording a video on his phone in which Exelby appeared with visible bruises. In the footage, he asked her, “This is how you wanted to die, right?” to which she reportedly gave a reluctant nod. Hall claimed he last saw Exelby on October 11 when she got into a tan Cadillac Eldorado with an unidentified individual.

When confronted by Special Agent Rebekah McKinzie, who led the investigation for the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Hall acknowledged that Exelby had sought his help to fulfill her wishes and expressed remorse, stating, “I failed her.” The police recovered a deleted video and found Exelby’s body in Marion County, Florida, on the same day the interview took place. She had suffered four stab wounds. The trial proceedings are ongoing.