Greater Manchester Mayor Bev Craig has urged the government to swiftly implement cuts to employers’ national insurance contributions (NICs) for younger workers in the hospitality and retail sectors. Craig’s comments came in support of a recent proposal by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn, who called for an increase in the NIC threshold for employees aged 21 to 24 from the current £5,000 to £10,000.
Under current rules, businesses do not pay NICs for workers under 21 or apprentices under 25 unless earnings exceed £50,270. However, for employees aged 21 to 24, employers must pay 15% on earnings above £5,000. Milburn highlighted the disparity in costs, noting that it deters businesses in retail and hospitality from recruiting young people. He recommended prioritising these sectors for tax relief to help address the challenge facing the one million young people not in education, employment, or training (NEETs).
Craig, who succeeded Andy Burnham as mayor in August, told reporters during a visit to a training centre in Salford that targeted support was necessary given the varied pressures industries face amid the cost of living crisis. “Hospitality firms have different cost pressures to international tech firms,” she said. Craig added that she hoped to see the government enact changes in the next financial year and emphasised the importance of focusing on sectors with limited investment in young workers.
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak acknowledged Milburn’s recommendations, stating the government was “very carefully” considering NIC cuts for young staff. The prime minister framed forthcoming welfare reforms as focused on creating opportunity rather than making across-the-board cuts. Meanwhile, Burnham, responding to questions, noted that while his predecessor’s government had increased employers’ NIC rates to fund public spending, efforts had been made to support young workers through initiatives such as the Youth Guarantee. He expressed openness to reviewing Milburn’s proposals but stopped short of a firm commitment ahead of future budget decisions.
Milburn’s report stressed the need to balance fair wages with manageable employment costs to encourage businesses to hire young people. “Young workers should not be cheap, but neither should public policy make the first hire unnecessarily expensive,” he wrote, warning that pricing young people out of the job market was neither progressive nor sustainable. His suggestions include phased extension of NIC relief beyond retail and hospitality, focusing on sectors with high potential for entry-level job creation.
The debate over labour market policies for young people has drawn responses from political figures beyond Greater Manchester. Shadow Education Secretary Laura Trott, while advocating for incentives to reduce youth unemployment, cautioned against structural changes to secondary education she suggested could be a “false diagnosis” of the problem. Trott was expected to address school leaders at an event in Birmingham, balancing support for welfare reforms with concerns over educational policy.
As the government weighs options ahead of the next budget, discussions continue on how best to support young people transitioning into the workforce while managing fiscal responsibilities.
