A federal judge has allowed a proposed class-action lawsuit against McDonald’s to proceed, rejecting the company’s request to dismiss claims that it misled customers regarding the type of meat in its McRib sandwich. The ruling was issued on October 30 in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.
The suit, brought by four plaintiffs, alleges that the McRib’s name, distinctive shape, marketing, limited availability, and premium price lead reasonable consumers to believe the sandwich contains rib meat. Instead, the plaintiffs contend that the sandwich is made from lower-grade pork products such as shoulder meat and, allegedly, other parts like heart, tripe, or stomach. They claim this misrepresentation causes customers to overpay for the product.
In her opinion, U.S. District Judge April Perry dismissed some aspects of the complaint but found it premature to accept McDonald’s argument that no reasonable consumer would expect the McRib to include rib meat. Judge Perry noted that while McDonald’s website describes the sandwich’s contents simply as pork, it could not rule out that consumers might reasonably infer from the name and marketing—including advertisements emphasizing the rib-like shape of the patty—that the sandwich contains actual rib meat. The judge said this could support a claim of intent to mislead, although further evidence would be necessary.
McDonald’s denied the allegations, stating it does not use hearts, tripe, or stomach in the McRib and has always been transparent about the sandwich’s ingredients. The company argued that distinctive product names are common and do not mislead reasonable consumers, and that customers’ preference for certain pork cuts does not transform accurate marketing into consumer fraud.
The McRib sandwich has been sold intermittently since 1981, with availability limited to select markets in the United States. The case could have broader implications for advertising practices and consumer expectations around product names and ingredient disclosures in the fast-food industry.
Plaintiffs’ attorney Thiago Coelho indicated his clients intend to continue pursuing the lawsuit to hold McDonald’s accountable for what they describe as deceptive marketing. The case remains pending.
