Alan Milburn, the former health secretary, has called on the UK government to implement a series of measures aimed at reducing youth unemployment and improving opportunities for 16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment, or training (NEET). His recommendations, outlined in a report released recently, include tax cuts for businesses hiring young workers, reforms to workers’ rights, and expanded support for mental health and education.

Milburn’s year-long review addresses the challenges faced by nearly one million young people currently outside the workforce or educational system. Central to his proposal is the reduction of national insurance contributions for employers who hire workers aged 21 to 24, with an initial focus on sectors such as retail and hospitality that typically employ a large share of young staff. He recommends doubling the earnings threshold at which employers begin paying national insurance from £5,000 to £10,000 for this age group over a five-year period. The aim is to make hiring younger workers less costly and more attractive to businesses.

However, Milburn advises caution regarding the regulation of zero-hours contracts. He acknowledges the risks these contracts pose to workers but warns that overly stringent rules could deter employers from offering jobs to young people, particularly in industries like retail and hospitality. This stance has prompted concern among trade unions, who argue that stronger protections for workers are necessary and that insecure, low-paid jobs are detrimental to young people’s long-term employment prospects.

The government has broadly welcomed Milburn’s report, with Prime Minister Andy Burnham describing it as a “watershed moment” in addressing youth unemployment. Business groups in retail and hospitality sectors have also praised the proposals, calling on the government to implement the tax and regulatory changes promptly. Organizations including the British Retail Consortium and UKHospitality stress that raising the national insurance threshold is critical to safeguarding jobs and stimulating hiring in their industries.

At the same time, some experts and commentators caution that prioritizing younger workers through incentives may disadvantage older jobseekers. Economists highlight potential fiscal risks and the uncertainty surrounding how technological changes, such as the rise of artificial intelligence, might impact demand for young employees in the future.

Beyond tax and employment reforms, Milburn emphasizes the importance of improving mental health support for young people, proposing national targets to reduce waiting times for child and adolescent mental health services by 2028. He also recommends strengthening early education standards to increase school readiness and numeracy and literacy by age five and 11, respectively. To enhance work readiness, he suggests introducing new performance metrics for secondary schools based on employment outcomes rather than academic grades alone.

A key feature of the proposed Youth Opportunity Service is the introduction of civic service programs for young people not in employment or education. This would involve voluntary work and skill-building opportunities, with additional payments and certification available for participants investing more time.

Milburn’s proposals have sparked debate over balancing the need for enhancing youth employment prospects with protecting workers’ rights and ensuring fair opportunities across age groups. The government’s response and the pace of implementation will likely influence how these recommendations translate into practice in the coming years.