The cast of the new Netflix series "Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story" recently shared their experiences portraying key figures in the infamous late 19th-century murder case. The show reimagines the life of Lizzie Borden and the complex dynamics within her household, emphasizing both the myth and the humanity behind the historic events.
Alison Hall, who plays Abby Borden, the stepmother, described her character as a "villainous and nefariously awful, sadistic" figure who frequently humiliates both the children and the household staff. Hall noted the character’s dark humor and theatricality made the role uniquely enjoyable. “She is also a kind of archetypal villain that you love to hate,” Hall said, highlighting Abby’s blend of cruelty and comedy. She took particular care in developing the character’s voice, drawing inspiration from mid-20th century actresses such as Bette Davis and Joan Crawford and aiming to create an “elitist sounding” and “bizarre” accent that felt both specific and unsettling.
Hall’s interest in New England culture, where much of the series is set, influenced her approach; having worked on other projects located in the region and living in New York’s Hudson Valley near Massachusetts, she immersed herself in local accents to enhance authenticity. Her portrayal sought to balance historical accuracy with creative interpretation, particularly through Abby’s distinctive manner of speech.
Meanwhile, Christina Beatty, who portrays Lizzie Borden, praised the series for addressing the mystery surrounding the murders head-on. She emphasized her focus on exploring the “human side” of Lizzie, a figure often obscured by myth and sensationalism. “I really loved just getting to be the human being,” Beatty said, underscoring the show’s intention to go beyond legend and consider the emotional reality of its central character.
The series, created by Ryan Murphy, has been described by cast members as a stylish yet grounded take on the Borden story, blending elements of dark drama and psychological thriller. The narrative features other characters such as Bridget Sullivan, the young maid and Lizzie’s love interest, portrayed by Vicky Krieps, adding layers of personal and social tension to the unfolding drama.
"Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story" aims to revisit the infamous case with fresh perspectives while exploring the intricate personal relationships and societal pressures faced by the Bordens at the turn of the century. The show’s portrayal invites viewers to reconsider the facts through a dramatic lens that combines historical detail with character-driven storytelling.