The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO) has confirmed it is not investigating Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski following a complaint related to his comments on medical assistance in dying (MAID). The Thunder Bay–Rainy River MP, who is also an emergency room physician, faced criticism after stating that individuals unable to access MAID could resort to other means to end their lives.

The complaint, filed earlier this fall by Claire Brosseau, who has bipolar disorder and is currently involved in litigation against the federal government over MAID access, questioned whether Powlowski’s remarks aligned with the ethical responsibilities of an Ontario physician. Brosseau argued that his statements effectively endorsed lethal self-harm, potentially undermining suicide prevention efforts and compromising the safety of vulnerable patients.

Powlowski, a co-chair of the joint House of Commons and Senate committee that reviewed the potential expansion of MAID to include those whose sole underlying condition is mental illness, opposes broadening access. The committee’s final report, released in June, recommended against expanding MAID on this basis, though the recommendation was not unanimous. In a supplementary opinion explaining his stance, Powlowski noted that even absent government approval for expanded MAID, individuals could and do end their lives through other means, citing illicit substances such as fentanyl as an example.

The situation drew the attention of House of Commons Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia, who expressed concerns that a regulatory probe into Powlowski might infringe on parliamentary privilege and restrict freedom of speech for members of Parliament. Scarpaleggia characterized the prospect of MPs self-censoring in the chamber as “unacceptable” and requested that Parliament’s legal team communicate this to the CPSO. In response, the CPSO acknowledged awareness of the Speaker’s stance and affirmed that no investigation is underway concerning Powlowski at this time. The regulator did not provide specific reasons for not pursuing an inquiry.

Powlowski welcomed the decision, emphasizing that it would be inappropriate for him to face professional repercussions for statements made in his capacity as a parliamentarian. He declined to comment specifically on Brosseau’s allegations.

The debate over access to MAID for those with mental illness continues amid ongoing legislative developments. The federal government introduced Bill C-41 in the fall, which would prohibit MAID for individuals whose sole condition is a mental illness but also includes provisions for advance requests for persons with conditions impairing decision-making capacity, such as Alzheimer’s disease. The current ban on MAID for mental illness is set to expire in March, prompting parliamentary study and public discussion.

Brosseau, while respecting the CPSO’s current position, indicated that the complaint process remains open and that she will respond to forthcoming correspondence from the regulator. She has not provided additional public comments pending the conclusion of the review.