A city initiative to plant new trees in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, has sparked concerns among local residents who argue that the placement of saplings could disrupt the neighborhood’s traditional Feng Shui and negatively affect their wellbeing.

The Urban Forest Plan, a citywide effort aimed at expanding tree coverage across New York City, includes at least seven new tree beds positioned directly in front of residents’ front doors on Bay 32nd Street and surrounding blocks. While the project is intended to improve air quality, provide shade, and enhance green space, some residents say the proposed locations interfere with the flow of “chi,” or energy, as interpreted through their cultural beliefs.

“For the Chinese residents who live here, this is not simply about the appearance of a tree. This is the entrance of our home... it can affect our sense of comfort and peace when entering and leaving our own home,” said Tina Tam, 65, a Bensonhurst resident, expressing apprehension about the tree placements. Her neighbor, Wendy Chen, 38, echoed the concern, noting that when they purchased their home, the absence of trees in front of the entrance was a deliberate and important factor.

Feng Shui practitioners warn that planting trees directly in front of doorways can block the “Ming Tang,” the space that welcomes positive energy into a home. Feng Shui master RD Chin explained, “Your life is blocked. There’s that symbolism that something is blocking your way…” He further clarified that while trees generally promote good energy, improper placement can have the opposite effect. Robert Luo, a local Feng Shui consultant assisting the community, suggested that poorly sited trees could attract negative energy, potentially leading to misfortune or health issues.

The city, however, maintains that tree locations were chosen based on practical considerations such as pedestrian access, underground utilities, and traffic infrastructure. The Parks Department reported that, as of fiscal year 2026, 18,261 trees have been planted citywide—the highest number since 2016—in line with Local Law 148 of 2023, which mandates urban canopy expansion.

City Councilmember Susan Zhuang has intervened on behalf of the residents, emphasizing the need to respect cultural traditions while advancing environmental goals. “Bensonhurst loves trees and wants shade on hot summer days, cleaner air, and greener blocks for our kids and seniors, but with respect to Chinese culture,” she said, expressing confidence that a compromise is achievable.

Representatives from the Parks Department confirmed ongoing discussions with Councilmember Zhuang and community members to address their concerns without delaying the broader tree-planting effort. They stated they are “always ready to work with community leaders and members to accommodate concerns when planting, while ensuring we fulfill our mandate to expand the City’s urban tree canopy.”