Several high-profile offensive coordinators in the NFL are encountering significant challenges early in their tenures with new teams, as they work to implement fresh systems and improve underperforming offenses.
Mike McDaniel, the former Miami Dolphins head coach, joined the Los Angeles Chargers with expectations of advancing quarterback Justin Herbert’s performance through a fast-paced, outside-zone run and rhythm-based passing offense featuring heavy pre-snap motion. However, the Chargers have struggled mightily, starting the season 0-6. Herbert, a two-time Pro Bowl quarterback with notable talent, is experiencing a downturn in play, throwing eight interceptions and posting a passer rating of 68.8—nearly 25 points below his previous career low. A weakened offensive line has compounded the team’s issues. Chargers head coach Jim Harbaugh acknowledged the ongoing difficulties, noting the coaching staff is exploring various solutions as the team prepares for its bye week. McDaniel expressed commitment to turning the offense around but conceded that the team’s recent performances, including a 22-6 loss to Kansas City where the offense managed only two field goals and 259 total yards, fall short of expectations.
In Tennessee, Brian Daboll, formerly head coach of the New York Giants and known for his role in the development of Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen, has taken over as offensive coordinator for the Titans. Tennessee selected quarterback Cam Ward with the first overall pick in 2025, hoping Daboll’s quick, concept-driven passing scheme that emphasizes run-pass options would accelerate Ward’s development. However, Ward has yet to find consistency, with four touchdowns, four interceptions, and a 75.0 passer rating through six games. Daboll acknowledged the growing pains of adjusting to a new system for a young quarterback and indicated satisfaction with the team’s direction despite unsatisfactory results so far.
Other coordinators are also facing similar hurdles. Frank Reich’s offense with the New York Jets ranks 25th in total yards and 27th in scoring. In Denver, offensive coordinator Davis Webb was stripped of play-calling responsibilities less than a month into the season, with head coach Sean Payton resuming the role. Meanwhile, Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts struggled under Sean Mannion before sidelined due to blood clots, and Sam Darnold’s performance has declined in Brian Fleury’s system with the Seattle Seahawks. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers, implementing Zac Robinson’s offense, have underperformed on offense, sitting at 1-5, with Baker Mayfield and rookie Jalon Daniels unable to generate momentum.
Conversely, some new coordinators have seen early success. Detroit’s Drew Petzing has led the Lions to the top of the league in scoring, benefiting from talent including Jared Goff, Jahmyr Gibbs, and Amon-Ra St. Brown. In Kansas City, offensive coordinator Eric Bieniemy’s return has boosted the Chiefs’ attack, even though head coach Andy Reid maintains play-calling duties. Running back Kenneth Walker III praised Bieniemy’s relentless approach to maintaining high standards within the offense.
The overall trend indicates that integrating new offensive systems poses a steep learning curve for many teams, particularly for young quarterbacks adapting to complex plays and terminology. While some coordinators have found a smooth transition, others continue to seek the right formula for success.