Northbrook residents have expressed strong opposition to a redevelopment plan for the Meadow Plaza Shopping Center, raising concerns about the potential demolition of a longstanding commercial hub near downtown. The proposal, which involves replacing the shopping center at 1901 Cherry Lane with three six-story condominium buildings, was the focus of public commentary during a Village Board meeting held on July 28.
Approximately 150 residents attended the meeting, nearly matching the turnout from a previous session on July 14. Although the redevelopment plan was not officially on the agenda, about a dozen residents spoke out against the project, some wearing yellow "Save downtown Northbrook" T-shirts. The proposal, initially presented by Pulte Homes Group in May as part of an early review process, would construct 150 residential units split evenly among three buildings, alongside commercial space and a public riverwalk.
Village Board President Kathryn Ciesla clarified that the plan remains in the preliminary phase and that no formal application has been submitted. She emphasized that there will be further opportunities for public input if the developer proceeds.
A significant topic of debate at the meeting involved the village’s involvement in the discussions leading up to the current proposal. Resident Dee Washburn cited records obtained through the Freedom of Information Act indicating that the Village Board had been actively engaged with the property owner and potential developers since June 2024. Washburn challenged Ciesla’s earlier statement that the village had not participated in the sale process, stating the documents reveal ongoing talks about development incentives, affordable housing, zoning, and redevelopment concepts.
In response, Ciesla questioned Village Development Director Amy McEwan about the village’s role. McEwan confirmed the village did not partake in the property owner's decision to market or sell the site but noted that the village routinely communicates with developers regarding zoning and planning expectations. “Anyone who’s going to develop land… will call my department” to understand what is allowable, McEwan said.
Meadow Plaza has been privately owned by a family trust for decades and was listed for sale earlier this year. Ciesla reiterated that if the current proposal does not move forward, the property will likely be sold to another developer, as the owners intend to sell regardless of the outcome. The owners have declined to comment.
Local businesses and residents voiced concern about potential displacement and impacts on the community’s character. Susan Nelson, a resident of 35 years and organizer of a coalition called "Save Downtown Northbrook," questioned the rationale behind the proposed six-story structures and the removal of long-established businesses. Several business owners, including Serah Cicek, whose coffee shop opened less than two years ago, described the plan as disheartening. Cicek said she was assured the plaza would not be sold when she signed a 10-year lease earlier this year.
In a statement provided after the meeting, Ciesla acknowledged the uncertainty facing current tenants and affirmed the village’s commitment to assisting displaced businesses through access to local commercial spaces and resources. She reiterated that the village does not control private property sales or leasing decisions. The redevelopment proposal remains under review, and further public engagement is expected if formal plans are submitted.