Hundreds of protesters gathered outside Oriel College at the University of Oxford on the evening of November 17 to oppose a talk by Nathan Cofnas, a blogger and academic described as a “race realist.” The event, organized by the university’s Reform UK student society and titled “An evening with Nathan Cofnas: is DEI undermining higher education?”, proceeded despite widespread opposition from students, college staff, and local politicians who expressed concerns about creating a hostile environment.
Cofnas, who has drawn attention for criticizing diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives in academia, notably sparked controversy earlier this year by accusing Professor Jason Arday, the youngest black professor at the University of Cambridge, of plagiarism. Arday denied the allegations but resigned from his post on August 5; he was subsequently found dead nine days later. Protesters outside Oriel College referenced Arday’s case prominently, chanting “Say his name – Professor Jason Arday” and holding signs reading “Remember Professor Jason Arday” and “Justice for Jason Arday.”
The protest outside Oriel was marked by attempts by demonstrators, some wearing balaclavas and keffiyehs, to block the college’s main entrances and force their way into the venue. Private security guards and, later, police officers protected the building, with protesters trying to breach doors and scale walls. Jolyon Maugham KC, founder of the Good Law Project—a group that supported Arday—was seen encouraging some protesters during the incident. Approximately a dozen police officers arrived and dispersed the crowd after the blockade continued for some time.
Inside the college, the audience was sparse. Estimates suggest fewer than 30 people attended the talk despite the lecture theatre’s larger capacity. Some attendees appeared disengaged as Cofnas spoke for nearly an hour about his critiques of the “race equality thesis” and his questions about DEI efforts in higher education. Cofnas reiterated his previous argument that under a purely meritocratic system, black individuals would be largely absent from high-profile roles outside of sports and entertainment.
During the event, Cofnas was asked whether he wished to apologize to Arday’s family, a request he declined, asserting that criticism of powerful figures like Arday at Cambridge had been suppressed for years. His comments received mixed reactions from the audience, including some applause.
The protests involved various groups, including Stand Up to Racism, Oxford Resist, and Black Lives Matter UK. Some college students who were not attending the event reported difficulty accessing their rooms during the protests, leading to tensions between them and demonstrators enforcing a picket line.
Oriel College stated it fulfilled its statutory duty by allowing the event to proceed despite the contentious atmosphere. The Reform UK society, which invited Cofnas, is associated with student supporters of Nigel Farage’s political party. The incident highlights ongoing debates around free speech, academic freedom, and the challenges posed by discussions of race and meritocracy in university settings.
