James Gray’s film “Paper Tiger” unfolds as a tense crime drama set against the backdrop of 1980s New York, exploring themes of ambition, family, and the corrosive effects of capitalism. The story centers on two brothers, Gary and Irwin Pearl, navigating financial pressures and moral compromises that lead them into dangerous criminal entanglements.

Set primarily in Queens, New York, in 1986, the film introduces Gary (Adam Driver), a retired police officer turned security consultant whose confidence and bravado mask deeper flaws. His younger brother Irwin (Miles Teller) leads a more modest life with his wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and their two sons. Gary visits Irwin’s home with a business proposition involving consulting for a Russian immigrant-run company engaged in illicit activities tied to the cleanup of the Gowanus Canal, an area noted for environmental contamination.

Gray’s screenplay highlights the economic struggles facing the brothers, reflecting broader social and economic tensions during the Reagan era. The film portrays how Gary’s arrogance and Irwin’s naivety contribute to their descent into violence and criminality. Their involvement with the criminal enterprise exposes the fragility of their familial bond and the moral compromises they make in pursuit of financial security.

The narrative is marked by Gray’s characteristic dark and intimate storytelling style, focusing on the complexities of family relationships within the framework of a crime thriller. Driver’s portrayal of Gary emphasizes a morally ambiguous character, while Teller offers a more restrained performance as the less worldly Irwin. Johansson’s Hester emerges as a grounded and resilient figure, providing emotional depth amid the unfolding tensions.

Cinematically, the film draws inspiration from American crime classics, recalling the family-centered gangster dramas of earlier decades. Elements such as its subdued lighting, explorations of loyalty and violence, and the brothers’ fraught dynamic evoke comparisons to “The Godfather” and the works of Sidney Lumet. An intense shootout sequence reflects influences from filmmakers like Michael Mann, underscoring Gray’s blend of classical and modern cinematic techniques.

“Paper Tiger” opens with a quote from Aeschylus’ “Agamemnon” that frames the film’s exploration of wealth, ambition, and the heavy costs they impose. Gray’s narrative delves into how ordinary people’s aspirations can devolve into greed and violence, illustrating a tragically familiar American story. Though the film’s elements do not always coalesce perfectly, it offers a compelling examination of personal and societal struggle through the lens of genre filmmaking.