Located at 1517 Lincoln Boulevard in Santa Monica, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery has long been a fixture in the Westside community, earning a reputation for its signature sandwich known as the Godmother. The deli, which has been in operation for over a century, attracts both locals and visitors with its freshly baked bread and generous fillings.

The Godmother features a selection of Italian cold cuts including prosciutto, mortadella, capicola, ham, and Genoa salami, complemented by provolone cheese. However, the sandwich is distinguished by what the deli refers to as “the works,” a combination of lettuce, onions, pickles, tomatoes, mayonnaise, yellow mustard, Italian dressing, and a choice of hot or mild peppers. This combination offers a balance of flavors and textures that has contributed to the sandwich’s popularity on the Westside.

While many in greater Los Angeles often hail the Italian-American sandwich at Pasadena’s Roma Market as a top choice, Bay Cities’ Godmother has emerged as a local favorite near Santa Monica. The deli’s commitment to freshly baked bread adds a distinctive crunch to the sandwich, reinforcing its appeal among patrons.

Bay Cities has become more than just a place to buy lunch; its counter and sandwich line serve as a social hub for the neighborhood. For those pressed for time, premade sandwiches are available in a display case near the cheese section, providing a convenient option. Customers can then take their orders to nearby Santa Monica beach, which is less than a mile away, making it an ideal spot for a casual picnic.

Over its 100-plus years of service, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery has maintained a blend of tradition and community engagement, securing its place in Los Angeles’ diverse culinary landscape.