In the year following Reform UK’s unexpected local election successes in May, the party’s pledge to implement substantial council budget cuts has largely failed to materialize, according to multiple assessments and statements from involved figures. Reform UK, led by Nigel Farage, had vowed to emulate former U.S. President Donald Trump’s controversial approach to government efficiency, famously associated with Elon Musk’s short-lived leadership of a so-called "department of government efficiency" in the United States. The party promised voters a rigorous downsizing of local government spending, including cuts to initiatives like net zero and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs.
However, Reform-majority councils across England have not delivered on these promises. Research conducted by the think tank PF Global, examining budget plans for six Reform-led counties—Derbyshire, Kent, Lancashire, Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire, and Staffordshire—found that only a fraction of the advertised savings were derived from genuine discretionary cuts when adjustments were made for inherited savings, statutory funding changes, and additional income streams. The actual discretionary savings in these councils ranged between £30 million and £44 million from a headline figure of £254 million, a proportion comparable to non-Reform councils.
Moreover, despite Reform’s repeated commitments to eliminate spending on net zero and DEI programs, PF Global’s analysis found no clear evidence of cuts in these areas. Instead, the reported budget reductions principally involved “corporate efficiency” efforts such as lowered consultancy fees, which mirrored actions taken by councils not under Reform control. Damayanti Chatterjee, a PF Global director, remarked that Reform-controlled councils’ spending patterns did not significantly differ from those of their counterparts, though they tended to raise council tax at a slower rate. However, a comprehensive evaluation of Reform’s fiscal impact is expected only after the publication of official outturn data in late 2027.
David Taylor, a former deputy leader of Worcestershire county council’s Reform administration, publicly resigned from the party nine months after the elections, citing frustration with the stalled reforms and a proposed 9% council tax increase. Taylor described the early discussions with Zia Yusuf, Reform’s former “head of Doge,” about orchestrating significant cuts as initially promising, but he later acknowledged that legal constraints, including data protection regulations, hampered the initiative’s progress. He concluded that while the reform concept was likely sound, it may have been overly ambitious and underestimated the complexity involved.
Opposition councillors concurred that the failure to enact dramatic cuts was foreseeable given the escalating costs and service demands, particularly in adult and children’s social care, which consume the bulk of local budgets. Adam Kent, Worcestershire’s deputy council leader and former Conservative member, criticized Reform for unrealistic promises and a misunderstanding of council operations. He noted that the first council meeting after the elections saw the previous budget largely maintained before the Reform administration enacted a substantial council tax rise, contrary to earlier commitments.
Experts outside the councils also questioned the feasibility of the “Doge-style” approach. Jack Shaw of Groundwork Research argued that targeting relatively small budget segments, relying on outsiders unfamiliar with local government, and expecting access to sensitive data was fundamentally flawed. Rob Whiteman, a former local government chief executive and head of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, emphasized that local authorities offer limited opportunities for rapid cost reductions due to a lack of widespread inefficiency or corruption.
In response, Ben Bradley, Reform’s head of local government and former Conservative MP, defended the party’s record, highlighting the challenging financial environment councils face and describing the past year as a significant learning experience. He contended that the UK lacks the powers necessary to implement the kind of sweeping reforms the party envisioned and framed their efforts as attempts to maximize value within an unsustainable system. Stephen Atkinson, leader of Reform-controlled Lancashire county council, maintained that efficiency measures had enabled the council to limit its council tax increase to 3.8%, below the permitted threshold.
Reform UK’s broader promises for local government transformation remain under scrutiny as councils grapple with tight budgets and growing service demands.
