The University of California (UC) Board of Regents is considering whether to reinstate the SAT as a required element in undergraduate admissions, a decision that could impact tens of thousands of applicants. The debate surfaced at a recent regents meeting, reflecting broader discussions on balancing academic standards and educational access.
Currently, UC does not require SAT or ACT scores for admission, a policy implemented in 2020 amid the COVID-19 pandemic and concerns over standardized tests’ links to racial and socioeconomic disparities. Instead, UC evaluates applicants primarily through high school grades and other factors. However, some faculty members and regents have raised concerns about the preparedness of incoming students, particularly in mathematics. UC reports indicate that average grades in introductory math courses have declined over the past five years, although overall retention and four-year graduation rates have reached record highs.
During the meeting, economists John Friedman and Jesse Rothstein presented contrasting views on the relevance of the SAT. Friedman highlighted research from elite private institutions showing that higher SAT scores correlate with stronger first-year college performance, even when controlling for race, gender, and family income. He likened test scores to a thermometer revealing underlying academic challenges, particularly among students from low-income households and underrepresented groups. Friedman advocated for attention to those foundational issues rather than dismissing the test outright.
Conversely, UC Berkeley economist Rothstein argued that the SAT provides only limited additional predictive value beyond high school GPA and primarily reflects family background. He emphasized that the choice facing UC is whether to use admissions policies to exclude students or to invest in supporting their success once admitted.
Regents expressed a range of perspectives. Regent Rusty Areias remarked on the longstanding tension between access and academic excellence in UC admissions. Student Regent-designate Jordan Roiland defended the performance of students admitted without test scores, noting average GPAs above a B level. Chair Maria Anguiano prioritized student retention and graduation outcomes over small GPA differences. Regent Scott Galloway, citing his own lower SAT percentile and admission to UCLA, questioned whether admissions officers lack the sophistication to interpret test information impartially. Rothstein responded that the increase in admitted student diversity since dropping the SAT indicates improved adjustment for bias.
Several students voiced strong opposition to reinstating the SAT, citing concerns over the cost of test preparation and potential disadvantages for low-income and minority applicants. UC Davis student Candice Phan, president of the UC Student Association, described standardized testing as a barrier to social mobility. Other speakers underscored the financial burden associated with preparation for these exams, which have become a multibillion-dollar industry.
The University of California sits in contrast to several other prestigious institutions. All eight Ivy League schools, along with Stanford, Caltech, and the University of Texas, have reinstated or plan to reinstate standardized testing requirements, citing their utility in predicting college success and identifying promising students from disadvantaged backgrounds. The University of Southern California is also reevaluating its test-optional policy.
Meanwhile, more California students are taking the SAT despite its optional status at UC. For the class of 2026, 138,763 students in the state took the exam—a 12.6% increase from the previous year. This rise is attributed in part to colleges nationwide reinstating test requirements. Many school districts provide funding for free SAT testing, often administering it during the school day.
The College Board, which administers the SAT, has proposed covering test costs at all California high schools for two years if UC reinstates the exam, potentially starting in the 2027–28 academic year. Though a nonprofit, the College Board reported $1.2 billion in revenue in fiscal 2024, with around $296 million stemming from SAT-related fees.
The regents have stated that applicants for current and next year’s admissions cycles will not be required to submit test scores. No decision has yet been made regarding the 2028 admissions cycle. As discussions continue, UC faces the challenge of responding to concerns about academic preparation while maintaining its mission to provide broad access to higher education.
