A landlord in Malmesbury, Wiltshire, faced a prolonged insurance dispute after a sewage leak caused significant damage to a flat he owns and rents out, resulting in delayed compensation for his tenant’s hotel stay. The incident began in April 2024 when blocked drains in the building caused sewage to back up into the landlord’s property from the flat above. The tenant initially attempted to manage the situation independently but ultimately had to relocate to a hotel until the problem was resolved, with the landlord covering the accommodation costs.
The building’s insurance, managed by Ringley—the block’s management agent—was held through insurer Axa. The landlord’s portion of the claim, which covered the tenant’s hotel stay, amounted to £1,010. However, nearly 30 months later, neither the landlord nor Ringley received payment. The total claim submitted by Ringley to Axa was £13,802, encompassing cleanup, repairs, and claims from another affected leaseholder.
Upon receiving the claim in May 2024, Axa engaged loss adjusters Woodgate & Clark to investigate. Loss adjusters, acting independently on behalf of the insurer, assess claims and advise on appropriate payouts. Despite the complexity, insurers typically resolve such claims within eight months. In this case, continued delays prompted Ringley to file a complaint against Woodgate & Clark, resulting in a £100 compensation payment in July 2026. However, this did not resolve the outstanding claim.
Following further intervention, the insurer eventually disbursed the full claim and awarded the landlord £1,400 in compensation along with £178.45 in interest for the delay. Ringley also received £1,196.64 in interest for late reimbursement of repair costs. An Axa spokesperson acknowledged the extended delay, expressing regret and confirming the total compensation paid to the landlord amounted to £1,578.
The delay was attributed in part to a separate drainage issue in August 2024, which necessitated additional cleaning and repairs, complicating the claim assessment. Scheduled drain repairs from May to November 2025 were stalled due to contractor illness and difficulties accessing parts of the building, leading to the appointment of a new contractor and further postponements. All repair work was completed by December 2025.
From January to July 2026, Ringley continued to press Woodgate & Clark and Axa for updates, but responses were inconsistent. Ringley cited staff turnover at the loss adjusting firm as a factor in communication breakdowns. Woodgate & Clark confirmed it was acting as an agent for Axa throughout the process.
This case highlights challenges some property owners face when dealing with buildings insurance claims following property damage, particularly when multiple parties and extended repair schedules are involved.
