Ron Holdway, who paid National Insurance (NI) contributions for nearly five decades, has discovered that his wife Lesley, with 13 fewer qualifying years, receives a significantly higher state pension. The disparity stems from the couple reaching state pension age under different systems: Ron qualified before 2016 under the old arrangement, while Lesley became eligible after 2016, when a flat-rate state pension was introduced.

Ron, 82, retired as a chartered accountant and reached state pension age in 2009. He receives the old basic state pension, which includes earnings-related top-ups, such as the State Earnings-Related Pension Scheme (Serps) or State Second Pension (S2P). However, being self-employed, he was unable to contribute to these schemes, limiting his entitlement. Lesley, 66, who retired more recently, receives the new state pension system’s full flat-rate amount as she has 35 qualifying years of NI contributions, including credits for caring responsibilities.

Under the current arrangements, Lesley’s weekly state pension exceeds Ron’s by approximately £53, amounting to nearly £2,756 more annually. Despite both pensions being adjusted annually according to the triple lock mechanism—which guarantees increases by the highest of inflation, average earnings growth, or 2.5 percent—the absolute rise for Ron is smaller due to his lower base pension amount. Over a 20-year retirement horizon, Lesley’s pension is projected to exceed Ron’s by about £55,000.

The pension divide between pre- and post-2016 retirees has sparked widespread concern among older pensioners, many of whom feel the system disadvantages their generation. Retired civil servant Rob Sharp described the discrepancy between the old and new pensions as “one great unfairness in recent history,” while former chartered surveyor Paul Green characterized the system as discriminatory, noting that the gap continues to widen each year.

The complexity of the old pension system lies partly in the supplementary earnings-related components, which were linked to additional NI contributions during working years. From 1978, workers could build entitlement to Serps on top of the basic state pension if they contributed to workplace pensions. Some older pensioners receive annual payments exceeding £20,000 under this system, while others who or whose employers ‘contracted out’ from additional NI payments receive less. This contracting out provided NI rebate savings but reduced entitlement to earnings-related state pension top-ups, fostering confusion and resentment upon the introduction of the new pension in 2016.

Experts highlight the declining relative value of earnings-related pension income compared to the flat-rate state pension, with concerns that many relying on Serps may feel left behind in future pension increases. Policy discussions include plans announced by Labour leader Andy Burnham to replace the triple lock with a double lock, which would guarantee increases by the higher of inflation or 2.5 percent but remove the wage growth link, with a promise to restore earnings linkage by 2030 if elected.

In addition, the government plans to raise the income tax allowance for pensioners to £13,036.40 starting next April—higher than the standard £12,570 threshold—aiming to provide tax relief to retirees drawing from both old and new pension schemes.