A new study analyzing three centuries of European portraiture has traced a gradual shift in Western beauty ideals, documenting a decline in the prominence of the hourglass figure long before the advent of modern media. The research, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, suggests that Western standards of female attractiveness evolved steadily between 1650 and 1950, moving from curvier to more androgynous body shapes.

The study was conducted by Jeanne Bovet and colleagues at Northumbria University, who examined 606 portraits of upper-class women painted across England and France during the 300-year span. These artworks served as "cognitive fossils," reflecting cultural values and aesthetic preferences of their times. To assess body proportions and perceived attractiveness, the researchers enlisted 1,525 volunteers who compared the women’s figures in the paintings to digital models with varying waist-to-hip ratios (WHRs). The WHR, calculated by dividing waist circumference by hip circumference, is commonly used to measure the degree of curviness; lower ratios correspond to narrower waists relative to hips, indicative of the hourglass shape.

Findings revealed a clear upward trend in WHRs over time, indicating that women were increasingly depicted with straighter, less pronounced curves. For example, Jean-Honoré Fragonard’s 1777 work The Souvenir, portraying a woman with an intricately cinched waist, yielded a WHR of approximately 0.51. By contrast, Robert Lefèvre’s 1808 portrait of Princess Borghese recorded a WHR of 0.62, followed by Pierre-Paul-Léon Glaize’s 1873 Before the Mirror at 0.72. A 1920s portrait of Hungarian violinist Jelly d’Arányi by Charles Geoffroy-Dechaume showed an even higher ratio of 0.78.

While some portraits deviated from the trend and fashion styles fluctuated over the centuries—including enduring cultural appreciation for curvy figures exemplified by icons like Marilyn Monroe in the 1950s and Kim Kardashian today—the overall statistical pattern remained evident.

The researchers note that shifts in fashion, such as the rise and fall of corsetry, have been well documented by historians, but propose that broader sociocultural changes were also influential. Bovet suggests that the traditional emphasis on a narrow waist and broad hips as markers of youth and fertility waned as European societies became wealthier, infant mortality rates declined, and family sizes shrank. Consequently, attributes like education and other qualities may have gained importance in socially communicated standards of attractiveness.

The results challenge assumptions that modern mass media initiated changes in beauty ideals. “People have always paid attention to appearances, usually because they wanted to send a signal,” Bovet said, underscoring the longstanding role of visual culture in reflecting social values.