When U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff met with Russian President Vladimir Putin at the Kremlin last week, the Russian leader cast doubt on Europe's willingness to end the war in Ukraine, according to sources familiar with the discussions. Putin referenced a contested claim that European nations blocked a peace deal negotiated in Istanbul in March 2022, an assertion denied by Ukraine’s leadership. Kushner and Witkoff pushed back against this narrative, portraying European countries as constructive partners in efforts to achieve peace.
The diplomatic efforts led by Kushner and Witkoff have been complicated by deep animosity between Russia and Europe, as well as mutual suspicion. The U.S. team has emphasized the potential for a postwar security arrangement in Europe to underpin a broader resolution to the nearly five-year conflict. However, the talks face significant obstacles, particularly after Russia’s initial demands included a rollback of NATO forces from its eastern flank—a condition European leaders have strongly rejected.
Kushner and Witkoff are not expected to participate in the upcoming meeting between former President Donald Trump, Putin, and Chinese leader Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, China. Instead, they will meet in Berlin with an eight-member European negotiating delegation appointed recently to represent the bloc’s interests in ongoing discussions with Russia and Ukraine. The European team includes senior officials from the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, and Poland, along with representatives from two European Union bodies and NATO.
The negotiations, which resumed with a face-to-face meeting of Russian, Ukrainian, and American officials in Abu Dhabi last week, revealed Russia’s demand to fundamentally revise the European security architecture. According to a document obtained by sources, Moscow called for reducing NATO’s presence in Europe and securing a sphere of influence reminiscent of the Cold War era. Russia also sought a formal cessation by the EU and NATO of classifying Moscow as an adversary, while urging them to abandon what it described as a course toward inflicting a “strategic defeat” on Russia. These demands reflect longstanding Kremlin rhetoric portraying Western support for Ukraine as an existential threat.
During the Abu Dhabi talks, U.S. envoys pressed the Russians on what reciprocal steps they would take to reduce tensions; Russian officials indicated they would consider some measures. The document also proposed mechanisms to prevent incidents, particularly in the Baltic and Black Sea regions, to minimize the risk of unintended conflict.
European leaders, especially from NATO’s eastern frontline states, have dismissed Russia’s demands as unacceptable threats to their security. Ukraine’s foreign minister, Andrii Sybiha, characterized the proposals as unrealistic, given Russia’s position on the battlefield. European officials, while skeptical about the prospects for success, have nevertheless engaged with the U.S. diplomatic approach seeking broader security discussions tied to the conflict.
Kaja Kallas, the European Union’s top diplomat, stated on Monday that there was no indication Moscow was prepared to move toward peace, underscoring the challenges ahead. Putin’s foreign policy adviser, Yuri Ushakov, acknowledged that significant progress would be required before European countries could fully join the talks involving Russia, Ukraine, and the United States.
As the Berlin meeting approaches, Kushner has expressed cautious optimism about advancing toward a “lasting peace,” emphasizing the need for practical compromises by all parties. The discussions will also address postwar economic and security support for Ukraine and lay the groundwork for further negotiations with Russia.
The Trump administration’s current diplomatic initiative seeks to integrate Russia’s broader demands regarding European security into peace talks, rather than focusing solely on Ukraine’s immediate situation. Analysts suggest Moscow’s objective is partly to weaken Ukraine’s ties with Europe and the West—a relationship that has grown stronger since Russia’s invasion. Observers note that a resolution of the war is unlikely without addressing the future of European security, which remains a central and contentious issue in the negotiations.
