After nearly three decades of cruising, travelers increasingly find that the size of a cruise ship plays a pivotal role in shaping their experience, often more so than the destination itself. Since passengers typically spend about 80 percent of their time aboard the vessel, selecting a ship that aligns with personal preferences, budget, and travel companions is critical.

Cruise ships generally fall into two categories based on size. Smaller vessels typically carry fewer than 1,000 passengers, sometimes accommodating only a few dozen to several hundred. In contrast, the largest cruise ships can hold thousands of guests. For example, the recently introduced Legend of the Seas and its sister ships have capacities reaching up to 7,600 passengers.

This spring, two of the newest ships demonstrated the spectrum of cruising experiences in Alaska’s waters. Windstar Cruise Line’s Star Seeker, which accommodates 224 passengers, and Princess Cruise Line’s Star Princess, with a capacity of approximately 4,300 passengers, both sailed the region in the summer of 2026. The Star Seeker debuted in December 2025 and has since moved to Asian itineraries, while the Star Princess, christened the previous November, is scheduled to spend the winter in the Caribbean before returning to Alaska for the 2027 summer season.

The choice between a large or small ship often hinges on the makeup of the travel group. For instance, the Star Seeker tends to attract older couples seeking personalized service, ample quiet spaces, and access to less frequented ports. Ed and Kathy Sayers of Westport, who are regular passengers on the Windstar line, appreciate these qualities but also enjoy the dynamics of multigenerational trips on larger vessels. “It just depends on what your goals are and who you’re traveling with,” Ed Sayers said.

Cost is another significant consideration when choosing between big and small ships. Smaller cruise vessels, particularly those classified as expedition cruises visiting remote or hard-to-reach destinations, often come with a higher price tag. Chris Gray Faust, executive editor of Cruise Critic, advises that potential cruisers carefully weigh these cost differences alongside the experiences offered.

Ultimately, the decision between a large or small cruise ship depends on individual priorities, including the desired level of social interaction, amenities, destination access, and overall atmosphere. Each option carries distinct advantages, offering travelers the opportunity to tailor their cruise experience to fit their preferences and expectations.