The new musical "Wanted" explores the complex lives of biracial twins who navigate identity and survival in 1893 Texas by adopting the dangerous strategy of passing as white. Directed by Stevie Walker-Webb, the production draws on period elements but injects a stylized, often lighthearted tone that contrasts with the gravity of its themes.

The story centers on Tallulah and her twin sister, Martha, portrayed as resourceful women who discover a knack for banditry after a confrontation with a hostile landowner convinces them that passing is necessary for economic opportunity. The musical’s costumes, designed by Emilio Sosa, evoke a 1930s aesthetic, creating a slightly anachronistic backdrop for the late 19th-century setting. The narrative oscillates between farce and drama, with heists that unfold as playful, almost cartoonish escapades rather than tense confrontations.

Visually, the production features an adaptable set crafted by Beowulf Boritt, designed to suggest multiple locations on a plantation with a skeleton structure of old timbers. Large scenic projections by Stefania Bulbarella complement the physical set, presenting imagery ranging from cotton fields to impressionistic sunsets and fluttering American flags. However, these visuals have drawn mixed responses, with some critics finding them overly artificial.

Musically, the show is anchored by the compositions of Baum and the lyrics of Chéri, blending styles from R&B and country to gospel. The score frequently pushes performers to their vocal limits, resulting in emotionally potent numbers. The cast is highlighted by strong vocal performances: Pfeiffer’s nuanced soprano, LaFontaine’s focused wails, Grammy-winning Ledisi’s ethereal presence as a guiding spirit, and Melody A. Betts’s commanding leadership of the Kinfolk chorus give the production dynamic musical energy.

Central to the narrative is Mary’s romantic entanglement with Jesse, played by Bradley Jaden, who represents a white man of ambiguous wealth. Mary’s decision to marry Jesse signifies her commitment to passing and introduces genuine emotional stakes into the plot. Her solo “The Way I Am” serves as a powerful moment of internal conflict and self-reckoning, underscoring the personal cost of living a double life.

Despite these strengths, the show struggles with tonal inconsistency and narrative clarity. Dramatic shifts appear uneven, as scenes with high stakes are staged in ways that lessen their urgency. For example, an attempted shooting during a wedding unfolds unrealistically, and subplots, including Tallulah’s troubles, are left underdeveloped. The presence of secondary characters like Elijah (Luke James) and comic relief maids Flo (Awa Salecska) and Sissy (Aurélia Williams) add humor but do not fully compensate for gaps in storytelling.

Further complications arise from historical inaccuracies and ambiguous character motivations. A key plot point involves Jesse being labeled a slave owner, a claim that conflicts with the show's 1893 setting, postdating the abolition of slavery by nearly three decades. This incongruity muddles the portrayal of systemic racial oppression in that era.

After over a decade of revisions, including a 2024 production at Paper Mill Playhouse, this iteration of "Wanted" remains a work in progress. Its length—approximately two and a half hours—may contribute to pacing issues, with some songs and scenes feeling excessive or redundant. While the musical’s ambitious engagement with themes of race, identity, and history shows promise, critics suggest that a tighter focus and clearer narrative could better realize its potential.

In sum, "Wanted" offers compelling performances and moments of musical and emotional depth but is hindered by uneven execution and structural flaws. The production raises intriguing questions about passing and self-definition, inviting audiences to consider what its characters truly seek beyond the surface of survival and escape.