Thanksgiving pies have traditionally been known for their simplicity and affordability, but this year, a growing trend of luxury pies commanding premium prices is emerging across the United States. From New York to Texas, bakers are creating elaborate, high-end versions of classic holiday staples, with some pies priced at over $100.

In New York, chef Michelle Kogan has designed a 12-inch pie featuring a crust made with Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal, filled with apple custard swirled with apple cider caramel and topped with gold leaf-adorned sour cream rosettes. This creation retails for $150 and has been touted as one of the season’s most expensive and innovative pies.

Meanwhile, in West Oakland, pastry chef Melissa Chou offers a 10-inch toasted wildflower honey custard pie with a delicate Italian pastry crust and beeswax-infused sabayon topping for $120. In the Hamptons, Lena Kristy sells brown butter apple streusel and cranberry pecan pies for $80 each, adjusting prices downward after a viral reaction to her $100 salty blueberry pie.

The rising prices and fancy ingredients have sparked debate among bakers and food experts. Ina Garten, a renowned figure in entertaining, expressed skepticism about extravagant pricing, suggesting that unless pies contained luxury items like lobster or caviar, their high cost was difficult to justify.

Proponents of the luxury pie market argue that quality and craftsmanship merit elevated prices, viewing these pies as comparable to high-end French tarts. Lena Kristy, who trained at culinary schools and worked in consulting before focusing on artisanal jams and pies, emphasized the thoughtfulness behind these specialty offerings. She believes pies deserve the same respect and valuation as other gourmet desserts, especially when they are meant to be shared and savored.

Conversely, some experts caution against losing the accessibility and tradition that pies represent. Iowa baker and author Beth M. Howard, whose documentary “Pieowa: A Piece of America” will premiere on PBS, insists that the value of pie lies in time and shared experience rather than expensive ingredients. For her and many others, pie remains a humble, homemade symbol of comfort and community.

The distinction between luxury and everyday pies reflects broader economic disparities. Joanie Spencer, editor in chief of Commercial Baking magazine, notes that while many still bake their own pies or buy affordable versions from stores like Costco—where pumpkin pie is a seasonal bestseller with nine million sold in 2024—there is a growing segment willing to pay for artisanal creations. For some consumers, a costly pie serves as a modest luxury and a way to create a memorable holiday experience.

This trend is not confined to major cities. In Texas, Goode Co. has collaborated with a jeweler to offer pecan pies priced at $70, with some pies containing golden tickets redeemable for diamond bracelets. In Missouri, Blue Owl Bakery’s Levee High Apple Pie, featuring 18 apples and a pecan-studded caramel glaze, can fetch $130 online or $69 at its Kimmswick restaurant. The pie honors the volunteers who built a levee protecting the town from historic floods.

Despite the rising interest in gourmet pies, some bakers point to a decline in overall pie popularity. Michelle Kogan, who runs a pie-focused bakery in Queens, sees luxury pies as a way to reinvigorate an all-American dessert amid changing consumer tastes. She notes that the complexity in preparation, quality ingredients, and rising operational costs justify the higher prices.

Yet, the debate continues over whether pie’s essence should be preserved as an accessible homemade tradition or reimagined as an artisanal luxury. As Beth Howard concludes, “Pie’s been around a very, very long time, so why do we have to complicate it like we’re doing with everything else in the world? Let’s just keep one thing sacred.”