Steven Engel, a prominent American lawyer with an extensive academic background and experience at major law firms, has recently been appointed as an examiner in the Chapter 11 bankruptcy case of Hughes Satellite Systems. His selection by a division of the US Department of Justice (DoJ) has raised concerns within the corporate bankruptcy community about the potential politicization of the examiner appointment process.
Traditionally, examiners—who investigate circumstances surrounding Chapter 11 filings—are appointed by the Office of the US Trustee, a DoJ division tasked with representing the public interest in bankruptcy cases. This process is typically technocratic and apolitical, involving feedback from stakeholders and limited involvement from the main DoJ offices in Washington. However, several senior bankruptcy lawyers report that, in recent months, higher-level DoJ officials have increasingly influenced examiners’ selections, deviating from customary deference to the US Trustee’s judgment.
The heightened scrutiny followed the dismissal of Tara Twomey, director of the US Trustee programme appointed in 2023, who was removed by the Trump administration in March 2025 and is currently contesting her termination on civil service grounds. Insiders familiar with the Hughes case indicated that the DoJ made a clear preference for Engel, though some creditors expressed satisfaction with his qualifications given his trial and investigative background.
Similar concerns surfaced in the high-profile First Brands bankruptcy, which involves billions of dollars in fraud allegations against the founder of the auto parts company. In that case, Martin DeLuca—a lawyer known for his pro bono work securing the release of Americans detained abroad and for representing right-wing technology clients such as Rumble and the Trump Media & Technology Group—was appointed examiner. Critics within legal circles questioned DeLuca’s selection, citing his comparatively limited experience in major bankruptcy cases, and expressing unease over perceived political considerations influencing examiner appointments.
Some lawyers argue that, prior to the current administration, political affiliation did not play a role in selecting examiners. One legal professional noted that the appointment process had historically been insulated from political influence, emphasizing the new developments as a departure from established practice. Another law firm executive revealed that their firm has actively searched for Trump connections to position themselves as potential legal support counsel in future examiner investigations, underlining the perception that political ties might affect opportunities in this sector.
Despite these concerns, spokespeople for the DoJ maintain that the examiner selection process remains apolitical. They highlight that the bankruptcy court must approve any nominee put forward by the US Trustee and assert that the department is committed to eliminating politicization and promoting transparency. The law firm Boies Schiller Flexner, where DeLuca leads the international private client practice, defended his appointment as the outcome of a competitive, stakeholder-informed process that was ultimately court-approved. The firm also pointed to its robust team of former prosecutors and bankruptcy lawyers as assets for managing complex cases.
Although opinions differ on the influence of politics in examiner appointments, the involvement of figures linked to former President Donald Trump has intensified scrutiny of future selections in significant bankruptcy investigations.
